Talk me out of a Merc

chasBMW said:
diesel sports car , isnt that an oxymoron ? , dont get me wrong it has its place my sister has a diesel freelander and its very nice

Tell that to Audi - didn't they do well in some well known 24Hr race?????? :rofl:
 
Rialas said:
........... Actually looking at that pic, my vote goes to the Merc......

but what about the face? :sick2:

20526-1.jpg

vyxiffewke.jpg
 
Nothing against MB, our Brabus tuned CLS320 CDI was a great motorway cruiser and was faultless in 3.5 years of ownership. The dealer and after sales experience was also much much better than BMW to date.

The latest SLK just isn't an exceptional or beautiful car. If I had to choose a convertible MB it would be the last model SL, but I'm not over 50 yet and don't play golf :wink:
 
No idea what weekly mileage you but I couldn't bring myself to buy a diesel sports car. :thumbsdown: Certainly not an open top. If you do make sure the stereo is very loud.
 
I test drove the SLK and was reasonably impressed with the diesel, on full chat it doesn't sound like a tractor at all. I would suggest that you test drive one and decide for yourself. Performance wise it is similar to the 2.0 ltr zed, my review is below

http://www.z4-forum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=16&t=36019&p=492883&hilit=Mercedes#p492883K
 
original guvnor said:
ronk said:
Stark said:
Diesel Sports? If an R8 came with the V12 Diesel......

Yes, they've all forgotten what Audi did at Le Mans. :D

Well it's hardly the pinnacle of competition is it? Audi vs Peugeot.

They don't seem to be doing so well against Merc and BMW in DTM.

LOL, cars running at full chat for 24 hrs and it isn't the pinnacle of competition.....okay give up what is....slot racing :poke:
 
When all is said and done - When we talk of BMW / Mercedes / Audi - Can we really say any of them are bad? Petol or Diesel
You cant put a fag paper between them.They all do what they are supposed to and do it well in my opinion.
 
I meant Sars - Audi are only interested in Le Mans because they have very little direct competition. Their boss of motorsport is quite frank and open about it. That's why they'll never do F1 because they can't GUARANTEE they will win.

So I stand by it. Le Mans is NOT the pinnacle of competition. Far from it.
 
Wow 37 replies in a few hours, thanks all!
The one reply that got me thinking was keep the zed I have!!
I could pay the balloon, get some new rims (dont like my multi spokes really) and a detail clean done it will look like a new car. I've only done 32k miles so that's no prob, just no warranty but can extend it for £700ish if I want to.
The main thing on a new one is that the payment of £560 a month was for private purchase and I get my cars through my business and that way will cost £700 a month as the dealer is telling me they get more help from BMW for private purchases!!
The Merc was on a 2 year lease by the way, loads off lease offers on Merc's at the mo, says it all really!!!
 
lux good said:
The Merc was on a 2 year lease by the way, loads off lease offers on Merc's at the mo, says it all really!!!
So we were comparing apples to
oranges all along. The reason I was baffled by the price difference.
 
original guvnor said:
I meant Sars - Audi are only interested in Le Mans because they have very little direct competition. Their boss of motorsport is quite frank and open about it. That's why they'll never do F1 because they can't GUARANTEE they will win.

So I stand by it. Le Mans is NOT the pinnacle of competition. Far from it.

As long as you have at least two teams then it is a competition, the OP didn't state that it was the pinnacle of the sport, just that a diesel won Le Mans which is still some achievement. More importantly the diesel in the SLK, does not sound like a diesel under hard acceleration, no clatter, just a deep throaty rumble.
 
sars said:
original guvnor said:
I meant Sars - Audi are only interested in Le Mans because they have very little direct competition. Their boss of motorsport is quite frank and open about it. That's why they'll never do F1 because they can't GUARANTEE they will win.

So I stand by it. Le Mans is NOT the pinnacle of competition. Far from it.

As long as you have at least two teams then it is a competition, the OP didn't state that it was the pinnacle of the sport, just that a diesel won Le Mans which is still some achievement. More importantly the diesel in the SLK, does not sound like a diesel under hard acceleration, no clatter, just a deep throaty rumble.

Not sure where you are coming from, the OP didn't even mention Le Mans. He just wanted to know whether to swap his Zed for an SLK. I stated that in my opinion Le Mans for Audi was not the pinnacle of competition and you took issue with that and i explained why I thought that. End of story.

As for a diesel in an SLK i have no quarrel with that. I don't like diesels and wouldn't buy one for myself but that doesn't mean i think they shouldn't make one. I don't want a turbocharged engine either (petrol or diesel) but they suit a lot of buyers and make a lot of sense.
 
Rialas said:
lux good said:
The Merc was on a 2 year lease by the way, loads off lease offers on Merc's at the mo, says it all really!!!
So we were comparing apples to
oranges all along. The reason I was baffled by the price difference.

Not really, i've looked into lease prices on the Zed and to get the spec I wanted wasn't far off the dealer price. Like i said Mercs are flooding the lease companies with special offers and BMW aren't!!
I'm going to get a lease price from Niche see how they compare.
Still think that keeping the 2.3i changing the wheels (keeping the multi spokes with winter set up on) and giving her a good detail might be the way to go!!
 
.....Just spoken to Niche who told me to contact a BMW dealer as all the BMW cars they have are coming off their site as they can't compete!! :o
 
Back
Top Bottom