Sports Car Vote - CLOSED

Poll Poll Random Sports Car Vote based on a few Car Mag articles - which would you choose

  • Porsche 911 -991 C2 - Approved Used

    Votes: 7 10.0%
  • Porsche 911- 997 GTS - Approved Used

    Votes: 12 17.1%
  • Audi R8- Used

    Votes: 7 10.0%
  • BMW M4

    Votes: 4 5.7%
  • Nissan GT-R

    Votes: 7 10.0%
  • Porsche Cayman S

    Votes: 5 7.1%
  • Jaguar F-Type

    Votes: 26 37.1%
  • Alpina B4 Bi-turbo

    Votes: 2 2.9%

  • Total voters
    70
  • Poll closed .
It's not on that list - and the Targas safe - but I was thinking this morning why the lotuses had not made the list - I don't think they have appeared very often in group tests recently - someone will prove me wrong.
 
My vote goes tot he F type for a few reasons:
I've driven every derivative from 3l to V8, roadster and coupe (most for a weekend :)). They sound awesome, look so much nicer than anything in the group and are well built.

Now the market has cooled they are becoming attainable to buy, but stil a head turning sight.

Of course those interested in pure performance should just get an Aerial or similar
 
jimmybell said:
i should add... my choice is amv8s or v12 when it drops a little more. I cant imagine servicing is that diff to porsche or jags.

F type Jags are in similar category to Porsche and BMW M service.

The V8 vantage service schedule is service every year or 10k. An annual service is £900 and Oil services are £495 from dealers. The engines seem fairly bullet proof and Aston services are renowned for being very good and take the customer seriously. Its sensors that apparently are the culprits on the V8.

This doesn't take into consideration the expensive parts and labour. But for a car of its pedigree its more expensive than the competition 911 etc Porsche servicing is very similar to M servicing in cost parts and labour are also similar.

A V12… well I'm sure its more expensive but the 12s apparently aren't as reliable as the V8s.
 
i *think* the v12 service is the same or very similar, per my convo with AM at FoS. The V12 isn't known to be unreliable, i think it's easier to work on (even if it's crammed in). The V8 however, i understand to be pretty solid, i read somewhere pretty much none ever fail.

The V12 would be the dream, i'd take the manual, and id love the V12 S too but price is £80k vs £130k+

The V8 i think is fine if you get the 420/430bhp versions. the 380 isnt enough, imo.
 
I take that back, see quote from Mike @ Bamford Rose dragged from another large forum:

"V8 road car in 5 years i have seen 3 failures not anything to do with customer misuse / abuse. In comparison a minimum of 1 db9 per month needing rebuild. I think this is evident in wider world, there are so many '9's advertised stating 'new engine fitted'. The V8 is generally bombproof whereas a neglected '9 could need a bomb to keep on road."
 
ZermattV said:
How my back would feel by the time I'd driven it to Austria - I love them - there is a lovely blue one locally - but all the others in the list i'd be happy to do 350 miles plus a day in for a week .

its a vey subjective list - perhaps we should do something similar when evo list there performance cars of the year and have our own vote ?

If every Porsche has similar seats to Tony's Cayman then your back would be much better after making that trip in my Evora - think you're probably right about the comfort in the Exige, but OG is right too - it's an awesome car.

I'm sure we could all add lots of cars to your list - but I'll make sure you get a ride in mine so you can fully experience the roar of the engine and the fizz of the air intake, it just keeps you coming back for more :evil:
 
ZermattV said:
Sounds a plan - a very glaring omission in my list :oops:

I've just checked and the new Evora is £72k, which would be the one being reviewed so doesn't meet your criteria.

Interested to know how many people have test driven the Jag. I'm currently telling myself I'm not old enough to drive one, but I am edging ever closer to another big birthday so this must not be the case soon :(

TBH every time I see Metal Lickers signature I wonder if my next car might be an E89, assuming I don't buy an M of course :roll:
 
I like the F Type convertibles, but the size of its rear window makes the Zed roadster's look panoramic!

Also agree re the orange colour. Saw one in the metal the other day - wouldn't be my choice.
 
jaRED said:
ZermattV said:
Sounds a plan - a very glaring omission in my list :oops:

I've just checked and the new Evora is £72k, which would be the one being reviewed so doesn't meet your criteria.

Interested to know how many people have test driven the Jag. I'm currently telling myself I'm not old enough to drive one, but I am edging ever closer to another big birthday so this must not be the case soon :(

TBH every time I see Metal Lickers signature I wonder if my next car might be an E89, assuming I don't buy an M of course :roll:

Surely your next car will be a lightly used Evora 400? :)
 
A good way of thinking of the answer... Sat (or stood) wherever you are right now working on a Friday afternoon, which would be the ideal choice to walk out of the office and get into? A V8 Aston would be pretttty nice right now.
 
ZermattV said:
Any more for any more before we declare the F- Type the winner

Won't matter how long you run it. The result is now a given with more than twice the votes of the second placed car.

I actually find the result really surprising on here since over a year ago when I first tested and posted there was a strong anti Jag and F type feedback.

How things change.
 
Yes but come on CJ....it's the only proper Roadster model in the list on a Forum made up of 95% roadster owners! It won't be up there in the biggest surprises of all time will it?
 
original guvnor said:
Yes but come on CJ....it's the only proper Roadster model in the list on a Forum made up of 95% roadster owners! It won't be up there in the biggest surprises of all time will it?
A white F-type was in the traffic queue outside my office yesterday lunchtime, I had a good look and found myself thinking 'mmmmm!'..... and it was a coupe... :o

I feel soooo dirty.... :oops:
 
original guvnor said:
Yes but come on CJ....it's the only proper Roadster model in the list on a Forum made up of 95% roadster owners! It won't be up there in the biggest surprises of all time will it?

That made me smile. Of course roadster owners like roadsters, but many of the listed models are also roadsters, Porsche, Audi, etc. and forum folks are more than capable of making sensible votes on cars :)

In 2013 & 14 when I made posts about F types they are not that well liked by many. Overpriced. Old mans car, etc. etc and here we see it the clear favourite and not by a slim margin.

Give it another year and you'll be out of denial about Jaguars and may even fancy the Coupe R :)
(And you know I'm only teasing you)
 
Back
Top Bottom