E85 Hydraulic steering conversion part 1

raymond.harper

Senior member
The P/S warning light come on in my 2003 Z4. My local garage said the column had failed. BMW wanted £2500 plus vat for new column. The car is only worth £3000 so not many options. Ergen in Sussex would convert to to hydraulic system for £2000 which was tempting but still quite a lot of money. I had read in the forum that two members in the UK had done the conversion. However they were no longer on the forum. Luckily for me one of our american cousins v8z4 had carried out the conversion in the states so I was able to contact him for help and assistance. After about 2 months I had gather enough information and parts to start the conversion. I will do this thread in two stages. This first one concerns the rack.
When BMW built the E85 they based it on the series 3 for the running gear. For some reason known only to themselves they did not use the same steering system but instead used the EPS which has caused no end of problems and was even the subject of a recall. Thankfully parts from the E46 series will fit.
2w4bs6d.jpg
The two racks compared. Pinions are very different.
The first part you will need is the E46 power steering rack with a purple tag. The purple tag refers to the badge on the rack which is purple in colour instead of silver. It has exactly the same turn to turn rate of 2.9 as the Z4. I bought a reconditioned one and some new tie rod ends total cost £200. If you are doing it this way this you will need to scavenge the tie rod nuts and cups from your old rack. The only thing wrong with the rack is that the pinion is smaller than the one on the Z4. The Z4 intermediate shaft will just not fit as it is too big. You will need the shaft from a Z4M which you can buy new from BMW for around £250. Ouch! With this shaft both couplings are the same size. What you could do is to get another Z4 shaft and get an engineering firm to swap the steering column pinion for the smaller shaft so that you will have one shaft with the couplings the same size. In a previous post concerning this the owner had merely removed the plastic guide cover and tightened up the joint to fit. I would strongly disagree . Either get the Z4M shaft or get the Z4 altered. v8z8 had a special one made up by a specialist.
2e21mdw.jpg
the two shafts upper is the Z4M
2eocf3r.jpg
the two shafts showing the difference in size.
For the first stage safely jack the car up and fix the steering straight ahead. Remove the key and lock the wheel. The wheel must not turn otherwise damage to the clock springs may occur. Remove the plastic undertray then the metal undertray. The rear four bolts point at an angle.Remove wheels. Remove tie rod ends. One came away easily while the other needed a bit of heat. Disconnect the intermediate shaft at the baulkhead, no need to remove the lower one , undo the two nuts and bolts holding the rack in place and simply remove the rack and shaft down.
30hvdat.jpg
Rack removed. Skid pan not removed but you need to remove it
You now need to assemble the new rack. As a rough guide the tie rod ends fitted onto the rack with about 20 turns. You can use the ones from your old rack but I would prefer you use new ones. You will need the tie rod nuts and caps as these were not supplied. You will need the black plastic cap on top of the pinion as the Z4 does not fit. The cap has a guide hole for the torq bolt so you know when the joint is engaged properly

You also need two torq bolts from BMW for the intermediate which are only £1 each. They have a blue coating to act as a lock and are single use only. Assemble the rack and get the rack into the neutral or straight ahead position. Offer it into place. A tight squeeze with the extra pipes on the rack but it does fit. Bolt into place. Now from inside the engine offer the shaft onto the upper steering pinion. It will only go one in one posion as there is a tab on the pinion. Don't push it fully home. from underneath line up the plastic cover to fit over the lower joint then once happy push it into position. As the shaft is sliding you can use this to place the joint so it lines up. Fit the old torq bolt not the new one. Now push home the upper joint and again use the old bolt. With the tie rods in place the whole thing should line up. Test from lock to lock. Once you are happy remove old bolts and torque new bolts into place. Mark the position of the bolts in yellow paint
10xamp4.jpg
new torq bolts note the blue film
Torque all remaining bolts. The first stage is now complete.
 
wow!!! awesome stuff!! your going to love the feel of this setup!! its a really great feeling unit!
 
Is some one going to offer this as a package deal fitted ????
I suspect it would be well received.
 
Certainly does look like an interesting project. Look forward to seeing further instalments as you connect it up, sort out a PS pump, etc.

Good warning on the shaft size. With such a critical part it needs to be spot on, not just clamped up tight
 
Great write-up OP. :thumbsup:

One of the few failings of the E85 (or in my case E86) is the EPAS IMHO - my E46 with the hydraulic set-up has much better feel!
 
Great write up :thumbsup:

Wonder whether it would be possible to obtain/manufacture a split splined reducing collar for the shaft size difference?

Look forward to the next instalment.
 
bladeowner said:
Great write up :thumbsup:

Wonder whether it would be possible to obtain/manufacture a split splined reducing collar for the shaft size difference?

Look forward to the next instalment.

Depends on the size difference but possible if of a high quality. I'd still be reluctant to have such a critical point with 2 set of splines and a single pinch bolt. Could be nasty if it failed..
 
cj10jeeper said:
bladeowner said:
Great write up :thumbsup:

Wonder whether it would be possible to obtain/manufacture a split splined reducing collar for the shaft size difference?

Look forward to the next instalment.

Depends on the size difference but possible if of a high quality. I'd still be reluctant to have such a critical point with 2 set of splines and a single pinch bolt. Could be nasty if it failed..

Believe me I have spent many hours researching this issue. The intermediate shaft is part of the safety system designed to crumple in an accident. It is on a sliding shaft and the pinion on the Z4 is completely different to the E46 and the Z4M. I think the old safe option is to use the Z4M shaft which is available from BMW part number 32-30-7-836-809
 
cj10jeeper said:
bladeowner said:
Great write up :thumbsup:

Wonder whether it would be possible to obtain/manufacture a split splined reducing collar for the shaft size difference?

Look forward to the next instalment.

Depends on the size difference but possible if of a high quality. I'd still be reluctant to have such a critical point with 2 set of splines and a single pinch bolt. Could be nasty if it failed..[/quote

In theory i guess you could get a splined slave made. But the only way i can see how it could be made would be wire cut. And the cost just wouldn't be worth it. There is only 1 mm difference between the 2 so a .5mm wall thickness. I am looking at other ways of doing it for my conversion. But what with work the and the baby i just haven't had time to look at it. I am hoping as the wife and baby are away this weekend i may get some time to work on my car or sleep!!
 
raymond.harper said:
cj10jeeper said:
bladeowner said:
Great write up :thumbsup:

Wonder whether it would be possible to obtain/manufacture a split splined reducing collar for the shaft size difference?

Look forward to the next instalment.

Depends on the size difference but possible if of a high quality. I'd still be reluctant to have such a critical point with 2 set of splines and a single pinch bolt. Could be nasty if it failed..

Believe me I have spent many hours researching this issue. The intermediate shaft is part of the safety system designed to crumple in an accident. It is on a sliding shaft and the pinion on the Z4 is completely different to the E46 and the Z4M. I think the old safe option is to use the Z4M shaft which is available from BMW part number 32-30-7-836-809

Thanks, it was just a thought. I don't intend to do this upgrade as my steering is no longer sticky but should the EPS fail - I certainly would as it is a great opportunity to improve the steering. :thumbsup:
 
Had a thought regarding this..

Will the upper column from the E46 not fit? If so, then surely this will resolve the splines issue?

Anyone know if it's just a std E46 column fitted to the ///M?

Mike
 
That would be a sensible idea. However the column looks different in that it has a rubber piece before the joint. Not sure if the length is the same on a Z4. Remember it is on a sliding shaft so has two lengths. If it was the same as a Z4 then it should work.
Some pictures here. http://www.vorshlag.com/product_info.php?cPath=1_8_281&products_id=502
 
Just grabbed this for a bargain £6.99 delivered!

Look at this on eBay http://www.ebay.co.uk/itm/160680041149

Had to be worth a punt at that price!

Also, if it does fit, I reckon my old column has got to be worth a couple of hundred quid a asl a used and working one?

Mike
 
2w4bs6d.jpg

I don't wish to labour this point but in this photograph I took comparing the Z4 to the E46 spindle you can see that the slot where the torq bolts goes through the shaft is different. The top part of the Z4 spindle is bigger. The Z4 shaft will just not fit. I am concerned that there is at least one car out there where the mechanic has just bolted the clamp down. The following was on the site but i believe the owner did not carry out the work and I have been unable to contact him.


688vnb.jpg
 
Back
Top Bottom