Subaru STI or 3L E85?

Hey all,

So I've just signed up and I'm currently trying to decide what to get next... I've narrowed it down to early 2000's Z4 3L or Subaru STI.

I know they are totally different cars and I have only driven a Subaru before, i know this is a long shot but is there anyone in Kent who would be kind enough to take me for a spin in theres!? Have any of you out there driven both?

Thanks in advance :)

Dan
 
Lynchy will have a 3.0 up fro sale very soon as he has just collected an ///M roadster.

It's an auto though, but might be worth giving him a shout. He is Dartford way.
 
Hello and welcome to the forum. Completely two different philosophy's on car type so good luck with that choice. The 3.0 Zed is a great car, the engine's a peach, decent torque makes for good drive-ability and a sound that makes you want to keep going, you sit close to the rear axle so you can feel the road and the changes in direction with your bum.

It's also a convertible, no brainer really :thumbsup:
 
it really depends on what you want for me the lack of 2 seats on the z4 is more than made up for by the convertible have you looked to see if there is one for sale near you on auto trader then you could have a test drive that way :evil:
 
Hello Dan,

Ultimately it depends on what you are looking for from the car?
Economy
Performance
Comfort
Fun
Daily
Weekender
Sunny days
all days

Both cars have a mix of and to an extent all of each of the above, at the end of the day it boils down to what is it you want from the choice?

:driving:
 
Welcome aboard :)

A strange comparison because, as you say, they're totally different cars.

sars has pretty much summed it up :wink:
 
Depending on the age of the Scoobies you have driven, you may be surprised how quick a 3.0i Z4 is in a straight line. The interior is also on an entirely different planet. Love scoobies driven a few, but never had an urge to own any car with a wing on the back.
 
Thanks for all your replies!

I must admit the Zed seems to be the one coming out on top.

Subaru's are so expensive, and when comparing what I can afford I get a hell of a lot more car I feel from the Zed.
Hopefully I can stretch for a 2006 onwards so I get that extra power!

I'll be keeping a very close eye on the sales section! Will let you all know when I find something :)!

Thanks again
 
Hello. New 2.5 zed owner and my first post to this forum.

First imressions on zed. Just fun car. Relatively cheap sports car with decent engine. No extra room for nothing, so cant think it as only car on household. Very, very great looking and turns heads even it has 12 years behind. Handling is good, but most of it is just feel of speed. When you drive 100kmh it feels just like 130kmh on modern car. I bet my f10 520d is just as fast on twists just without fear. But again z4 isnt race car so feel is everything. Build quality isnt like sedan bmw level (was it build by americans?). All looks, feel and lots of fun. Best in sunny day, polished, modest speed, twisty road and of course roof open. If you worship looks and feel this is your car.


And scooby. In past I had 331hp modded forester xt. Sti might be different, but engine was about mapped/lightly modded sti. Also forester chassis/drivetrain is very close to wrx. Subaru in general have maybe one of best build qualitys, far better than bmw. Engine was full of anger and it pulled hard. 1st and 2nd gear were just violent. Like going to 100kmh wasnt accelerating, it was just like selecting 100kmh. Havent driven 3.0zed but cant think it be anything like that. Subaru is planned by engineer not designer. Every switch feels like it is going to last forever an built like in army trucks in good and bad. Interiors are awfull 90"S desing, so are exteriors, terrible noise inside and gas mileage is just awful. Sti is race car based on sedan and then retamed back to road. So scooby is all engine, reliability, and 4wd. Without power not much left to buy. But if you worship power....

Both have much more character than most of brands. Fond memories on scooby and really in love to z4, just different. You can buy scooby to your only car but z4 will make neighbours jealous.
 
Back
Top Bottom