If you feel it's time for a change of type of car and you like the styling you won't find a better car! I am loving mine (even more than the Z4 to be honest).
I've put over 4,000 miles on it so far and hasn't put a foot wrong yet. Talking of reliability, that is better than my Z4 E89, as that broke down on the 2nd day of ownership! (the well documented HP fuel pump failure!) :wink:
Not really a bad car made these days but you can get the Friday car of any make. There was someone on here that posted about loads of things going wrong with their new Z4, and it is the same on any forum of any make.
Take a test drive. I'd go for the diesel auto also as the petrol could return worse MPG than my Z4 did! If you plan on carrying passengers in the back a few times, I'd go for the 5 door as the Coupe's seats are pretty slow at pulling forward and the gap could be a bit of a squeeze to get in if the passengers are not of an athletic build! :wink:
I went for the coupe as I like the look and you get the bonnet vents!

They will surprise you on the handling also! The Dynamic mode firms up the suspension a lot, but I find it's almost to hard! The standard setup is great.
I have taken it off road a few time in Wales and it's very good!
Don't get me wrong, I loved the Z4's I've owned, but it was time for a change! I did a complete change! Went from a black 2 seater manual sports car, white interior, rear wheel drive with a 3L straight 6 petrol engine to a white 4x4 with a black interior, auto, 4 wheel drive, 2.2 L Diesel engine 5 seater!! Haven't regretted it once!
I think when you feel it's time to change then there is no looking back.
Link to my post about my Evoque if you fancy a read:
http://www.z4-forum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=16&t=50839