Impact on our youngsters?

Education secretary Nicky Morgan is saying that brexit will effectively leave a generation on welfare as the UK would struggle to find a trade foothold again in Europe, in a nutshell claiming the EU wouldn't hire UK people, and we would have a shortage of work due to lack of investment from other shores. As a dad of a 9 year old it's important to me that I take into account the possible consequences of my vote on not just my but everyone's children.

Is Morgan spouting propaganda to help the government win or does she have a genuine valid point.

Anybody care to express their views on this, you have to admit, pretty important subject?
 
Yeah and don't forget the world will stop revolving at the same time. I do wonder how much clap trap we are in for in the coming months. :headbang:
 
Given that the UK imports vastly more stuff from the EU than we sell to them, they would be committing financial suicide to start a trade war with us. So I'd put that one down as misinformation.
 
Bottom said:
[post]1270578[/post] So I'd put that one down as misinformation.

+1 All politicians spout propoganda. My advice would be to do your own investigations, can't trust any of 'em. :thumbsup:
 
A tried and tested Political ploy: Not worried about your own future? - then worry about your children's future.
 
I've just read the same article, very prominent on the BBC home page, surprise! surprise!
I tend to agree it's government propaganda and it's part of the hype that's will be heard till the election, one could argue the other way and that there will be more jobs available for UK members if we repatriate some of the EU migrants.

A little off the subject but my decision on whether to leave or not will be whether Turkey and other East European states are to be part of the EU. No disrespect to anyone from Turkey but I don't think they are sufficiently stable politically.
 
john-e89 said:
Education secretary Nicky Morgan is saying that brexit will effectively leave a generation on welfare as the UK would struggle to find a trade foothold again in Europe, in a nutshell claiming the EU wouldn't hire UK people, and we would have a shortage of work due to lack of investment from other shores. As a dad of a 9 year old it's important to me that I take into account the possible consequences of my vote on not just my but everyone's children.

Is Morgan spouting propaganda to help the government win or does she have a genuine valid point.

Anybody care to express their views on this, you have to admit, pretty important subject?

Whilst I believe an exit is overall bad for the country and we should remain in on better terms the Education secretary (sic) is talking mostly scare monger bollocks!
 
Its a shame they haven't had this crystal ball for the last 20 years, it would have saved various governments from some of the mistakes they made. Remember when they said attacking Iraq was definitely in our best interests?

I don't know where they dream this stuff up from. I also don't see how the politicians seem able to say ANYTHING they like and not show any facts or back their claims up.

As we keep being told, we manufacture less in the UK than we used to. Fair comment. So the ''stay in'' camp say that all the countries that supply these goods from the EU will stop doing so???? The likes of BMW, Mercedes, Audi, VW, Siemens, Bosch, Peugeot (Hopefully), Citroen (Hopefully), Wine, Champagne, Brandy, etc,etc,etc. The notion that the tap will be turned off is ridiculous. Im sure some relationships will change but I believe that EU companies will be banging down doors to remain trading with the UK. So do BMW not sell cars outside of the EU? How about Champagne from France, do they drink much of that in the US? Presumably by the same notion, they would have us believe Spain will be turning us away at the border in our hundreds of thousands? Its a load of scaremongering b#llo##s.

If for some unbelievable reason, the EU won't trade with us, we will presumably need to manufacture all of the goods we currently import from the EU. This will surely then mean the creation of lots of uk jobs in all of these sectors that are now unable to trade with us and the loss of the jobs of the people in the EU, who won't be selling us goods.

As for the imminent inclusion of Turkey into the EU, this should be enough for everyone to vote leave.
 
john-e89 said:
Education secretary Nicky Morgan is saying that brexit will effectively leave a generation on welfare as the UK would struggle to find a trade foothold again in Europe, in a nutshell claiming the EU wouldn't hire UK people, and we would have a shortage of work due to lack of investment from other shores. As a dad of a 9 year old it's important to me that I take into account the possible consequences of my vote on not just my but everyone's children.

Is Morgan spouting propaganda to help the government win or does she have a genuine valid point.

Anybody care to express their views on this, you have to admit, pretty important subject?


Care to take a look at the youth unemployment stats for the rest of the EU?

My children have made up their own minds and are 100% for leaving.
 
Oh, and don't forget that the current status quo option will not be on the ballot paper.

We're either in the EU for greater integration, further loss of sovereignty, more loss of control etc. etc. etc. as the "european project" progresses.

Or we're out with the freedom to make our own decisions.

Staying as we are today just isn't an option that's on offer.
 
Wished there was a definite list of items on the pro or con table.

For example, is the human rights court in Strassbourg part of the EU discussion or not? If voting No means being removed from that burden, it would be a huge benefit to the national security to be able to get rid of the muslim clerics of hatred and therefore the amount of terrorists being grown in the UK.

Also, if staying IN the UK means that we have to open the doors to Turkey, then that is a disaster to happen as well.
 
PVR wrote_
For example, is the human rights court in Strassbourg part of the EU discussion or not? If voting No means being removed from that burden, it would be a huge benefit to the national security to be able to get rid of the muslim clerics of hatred and therefore the amount of terrorists being grown in the UK.
It would be good to know what the stand on this is, if we left and could establish our own set of rules, that, plus Turkey knocking on the door, the vote becomes a no-brainer.
 
pvr said:
Wished there was a definite list of items on the pro or con table.

For example, is the human rights court in Strassbourg part of the EU discussion or not? If voting No means being removed from that burden, it would be a huge benefit to the national security to be able to get rid of the muslim clerics of hatred and therefore the amount of terrorists being grown in the UK.

Also, if staying IN the UK means that we have to open the doors to Turkey, then that is a disaster to happen as well.

True, it would be good to get definitive answers to these question; but failing that, one would hope a vote to leave would move us closer to those wishes than a vote to stay in.
 
pvr said:
[post]1270612[/post] Also, if staying IN the UK means that we have to open the doors to Turkey, then that is a disaster to happen as well.

Unfortunately it's a very complex issue which requires too much information for your typical Joe Public to digest. I'm not even sure there should have been a public referendum held in this manner. What government run website shows clear pro/conns of Europe in an easy to read unbiased way? Seems easy for me to file tax returns - but they can't manage something like this? I've searched - I can't find it. There should be public debates on national television during prime time - instead you get Eastenders. David Cameron's rush to appease the voters will back fire without the proper attempt at education - unfortunately the very people who need to educate us aren't trusted, another issue entirely ...

Your archetypal Joe Public wants to Sun/Daily Mail style headline questions with multiple choice tickboxes. "Why should we stay in Europe: Jobs, Why should we leave: Muslims.". It's pretty depressing how ignorant many people have become, especially in such complex matters - a few bombs go off, a few media headlines about how "immigrants ruin everything", and it's easy to shift a large % of the population. European issues are being used as a scapegoat, these issues are nothing to do with Europe, yet somehow it has all been bundled all together. Are we saying No to Europe because we think our membership into the EU attracts this unwanted attention? Because Belgium was bombed we'll be safe if we say no? Just what the billionaires of the world want; they are the ones who own the media you read after all. There's much more unbiased information at our finger tips than ever before - but who's reading it?

"Leave Europe, stick our fingers up to Brussels, that'll show 'em. Those Muslims, we don't want any of that here - leave Europe."
Every article which tries to explain positives of staying in Europe must be pure scare mongering after all? Good old English values.

People need to wake up and realise we're not a super power, we're not even relevant in the World theatre - we'll become another Iceland. Scotland will want to be in the EU, so will Ireland. Our currency will de-value (which it has already significantly - costing my small business a fortune already). How many of you here have been directly affected? I bet those with the strongest opinions have the least to worry about either which way! Our IT industry and engineering abroad will suffer. It will have a negative impact - that is a fact. How many here have been through the Visa process for recruitment or living abroad? You tell me that queuing up with people from third world countries in order to set-up a business abroad is a positive step. I've set-up companies in countries not in the EU and exported to the UK - it was a nightmare. Cross fertilisation of talent, importing/exporting - it's all problematic. Sure, it can be done - but given the choice between working with Germany and the UK, other EU countries will chose Germany every time, purely due to paperwork. I'm on the ground in Europe and I see how things work.

But it's OK, we can say no to immigrants and stick our fingers up to Brussels.

Most naysayers I speak to can't list 10 positive things about Europe - so much for a balanced argument. You can't say "no" to Europe because of problems of immigration, all of Europe is suffering at the moment - it's a world disaster what's happening in Syria. Blocking Europe will not change that - the UK would accept a certain amount regardless. This is a decision from which there is no turning back - look 20-30 years into the future, look past the Sun headlines and look at the bigger picture. /rantover - *takes me flame proof coat and hides in a big box which says - Open July 2016* :fuelfire:

:thumbsdown:
 
Slightly tongue in cheek but I'm surprised Marlon hasn't come up with a poll on this yet... :wink: :D
Stevo
 
I've recently had the opportunity to work in collaboration with colleagues in several European counties and about 100 15-16 year old students. This has been something new to me and I've a somewhat scary observation which should scare the hell out of every uk jobseeker.

Every single colleague could do their job in the UK and none of the U.K. Folk could work anywhere else in Europe.

Every single one of the students could study or work in the UK and none of the U.K. Students could work effectively anywhere else in Europe.

So here s the thing. 300 plus million people can apply for any post in Europe. U.K. Folk have access to perhaps 20% of that job market. No wonder folk from abroad take 'our' jobs, they're more employable than we are. Our kids don't want to work in hospitality, nursing, and other service industries, they're not really interested in manufacturing and engineering. They either want to do nothing or be lawyers or work in media and the arts.

No idea if we're better in or out but I do know that if you're 15 then get educated, get a language other than English and stop looking for an easy ride.

Grump over!



.
 
Sorry not read the whole post. But if it helps. I think it's possible a vast oversimplification of an issue. I have just recruited a grade 5 tech in a university. So 25k ish. I could employ anyone from EU with no issue. I could try to employ outside of the eu but I would have to justify it and probably wouldn't be able to as there would more than likely be uk/eu candidates. We did interview a non eu but his visa was covered by the fact he'd PhD'd here so could get 2yrs.
I suspect his comments would revolve around visa issues in the eu. It will take time to get agreements in place. How much time who knows?
 
Back
Top Bottom