How would YOU have dealt with this situation (long winded)

dario

Senior member
The other day I visited a restaurant in Anglesey when I was working at the race track helping a couple of semi pro drivers with data whose team had privately hired the track for the day.

I was recommended this restaurant by the landlord of the local guest house I have decided to stay at for the umpteenth time (Prince Llewellyn guest house just a mile of so from the track.

From outside the restaurant was vey good looking and built in the style of a Huff house. The internal furnishings and decor were modern and completely out of character for the area in which it was situated. Being greeted warmly by the staff, they showed me to a table of which I had a few to choose from. Once seated I was asked what I wanted to drink and a menu was left with me to peruse.

I choses a prawn cocktail to start with and a Welsh beef steak as my main course. I know the selection lacked imagination, but it was a “safe choice”. Some time passed and duly arrived my starter. I was a little disappointed on its presentation as is was served in a short dumpy tumbler, especially as it was nearly £6! When the waitress came to my table and asked the obligatory question of “was everything ok”, I took the opportunity to give my opinion (politely) that the way in which it was presented lacked imagination and was akin to the way it might have been served up in the 70’s and not representative of it’s cost!

The waitress apologised and went to the kitchen to find out why it was served this way. Upon return she said that the kitchens had admitted to having a new employee working on the preparation of the starters and it was his inexperience that had caused the starter to be served this way. I didn’t need an apology, all I was trying to do was pass a comment that it just didn’t look right served this way and it didn’t look worth near £6.

All through this amicable discussion with the waiting staff I kept getting glared at by a woman seated in a group of 3 women at a nearby table. I couldn’t figure out why, but it wasn’t a glance, it was a glare.

Then the steak arrived which I had ordered medium to well done. Presentation was good with double cooked chips and some huge onion rings with a blob of herb flavored butter on the steak. Cutting in to the steak it looked a little bloody for my tastes but not too bad so I continued cutting it up and would have finished it had it been the same all the way through. Another slice in, and low and behold it was next to raw. I beckoned the waitress over and turned the plate around so that she could see the cut in the steak and I asked her is she remembered how I had asked for my steak to be cooked. Getting the ticket from the kitchen she confirmed that she had conveyed my request to the kitchen correctly. Looked to my left and again the woman was glaring at me.

The female manager came over, apologised and said that another one would be done fresh for me. She then stated that it would be on the house. At this I said NO, I wanted to to pay, I had no problem with paying for what I had ordered and I had not complained just to get a free meal!

Now all through this I was cool and collected and courteous to the waiting staff as its not my way to be rude first. But if they give me $hit, they’ll get it straight back with interest!

When I had finished my meal (more apologies from the staff) which had arrived properly cooked and nicely presented, I got up from my table and walked in the direction of the 3 women. When level with them another woman in the group asked me if I was a food critic? I politely responded no, but as I was being asked my opinion of this restaurant by friends that were visiting the area later in the month I was conscious of what I was being served and as it happened I was asked my opinion on the starter and had to send back my steak because it was not properly cooked. I then queried as to why she asked this of me and she responded “I though you were RUDE!”

Taken aback somewhat, I explained that I had not been rude and it was a matter of her opinion. I also stated that the conversation between me and the waiting staff has three components. Verbal communication, eye contact and body language. The last two she had not been privy to and so could not form an opinion on what had gone on.

She still maintained that I had been rude. At this point I was in two minds as to how to continue this conversation. So much so, that I went and fetched each of the waiting staff to her table and asked them if they thought I had been rude to them in turn. Each responded emphatically with “no”. Still unconvinced by all my witnesses, she still proclaimed that as far as she was concerned I had been rude. It was at this point that I walked away.

I wish I had shown her how rude I could be, but I didn’t, I stayed the gentleman!

What I want to know, is how would you have dealt this this situation. Don’t forget that your decision has to be made on the spur of the moment like mine was?
 
Well I had my answer as soon as you got to the part where she told you she thought you had been rude. I would have told her where to stick her opinion with a very graphic description involving some very colourful language, a smile on my face and polite "good evening ladies" with a tip of the old imaginary hat before turning on my heels and happily continuing with my evening.

Life is too short to waste time arguing with idiots. They will drag you down to their level and beat you with experience.
 
I think it's fair to point out, even if you had been rude, the waiting staff wouldn't have admitted it. (I'm not saying you were, just waiting staff would always avoid confrontation)

Personally I would have told her that I think she was being rude and then I would have probably been rude.
 
You did the right thing by not lowering yourself to her level. I myself would have gone further in a polite way. In that I would call her bluff and ask in what way she thought I was rude. I may have even asked her If she had received a rare steak having ordered it well done what would she have done.

For some reason. There are more than a few people out there that live such a loathsome life. They just look for ways to be offended or try to run others down to make themselves feel superior.
 
People think theyre entitled to do / say what they want these days. You are paying for a service, you are unhappy with that service, that service has not lived up to its reputation.

Especially as you declined the offer of a free meal I dont see how that can be rude but then its all down to perception.. Ignore it and move on life is too short to dwell for time on this sort of "incident". You did what you thought was right and that is all that can be expected of us all.
 
Why even waste one second of your time on some random self-appointed grand poobah of manners?

Just smile pityingly and walk away.
 
Some people consider any type of challenge or expression of dissatisfaction as being "rude".... regardless of whether you do it in a polite way or not.

I wouldn't have pointed out that it's rude to stare, then left....

You did well my man :thumbsup:
 
thanks for everybody's replies. After the event I was full of ideas of how i should have dealt with it from somewhere close to the comment made by scousefly which would have given me satisfaction! But what she said troubled me for the remainder of that evening and the remaining day.

I bet if theres another time....... possibly mrPT idea of the frying pan in the face might have great comedy value and satisfaction. I'm planning on going back there on Monday evening as i'm working with the team again testing changes made to the car.

Thanks everybody for the input.

Dario
 
thanks for everybody's replies. After the event I was full of ideas of how i should have dealt with it from somewhere close to the comment made by scousefly which would have given me satisfaction! But what she said troubled me for the remainder of that evening and the remaining day.

I bet if theres another time....... possibly mrPT idea of the frying pan in the face might have great comedy value and satisfaction. I'm planning on going back there on Monday evening as i'm working with the team again testing changes made to the car.

Thanks everybody for the input.

Dario
 
Firstly I would have accepted the steak on the house :D (they did get it wrong).
Secondly I may have told the lady at the table that she should have been minding her own business as the dialogue was between you and the waiting staff +\- adding on that there clearly couldn't have been much good conversation at their table for her to be so distracted by you (depending on my mood).
Think you handled it well by not losing it but you shouldn't have had to confirm to her with the waiteress involved. That's just giving the lady and her interfering comment too much importance.
 
Dario, I know what you mean about something like that troubling you for the remainder of the day.

I had a situation this week where an old friend of mine has really been quite nasty with me and told me I've been selfish and offensive because I objected to him running up a £250 per person drinks bill in a nightclub, supposedly on my behalf, and because I told him I wasn't going on his brothers stag do's (frankly I can't afford their weekends away). Unusually for me I've struggled to brush it off since it happened on Tuesday. Stupid really because I bet he hasn't given his behaviour a second thought.
 
original guvnor said:
I objected to him running up a £250 per person drinks bill in a nightclub, supposedly on my behalf

That's outrageous. I'd point blank refuse to pay, no friend would behave like that. :thumbsdown:
 
You did the right thing buddy. Its your money your spending not hers. And the staff seemed happy with your comments. Unfortunately it sounds like you have meet my mum!!!
 
Machine monkey said:
You did the right thing buddy. Its your money your spending not hers. And the staff seemed happy with your comments. Unfortunately it sounds like you have meet my mum!!!
OUCH!

I was thinking he'd met my mother in Law. Whom upon hearing that the wife and I were moving from South Dakota to Washington state (900 miles away). Asks her daughter with whom she is very close to mind you. Who is going to clean my house and do the laundry when you move? No. It wasn't I'm going to miss you very much. Her first thought was about herself. Which was rather hurtful for my wife. Much against my nature. I choose to keep my mouth shut until the wife asked me about it in private.
 
Back
Top Bottom