Thanks Greg, tried that but still not working. The lid works without the silver top absolutely fine, when I put it back on, won't close.
On the odd occasion I do manage to close it, it still does not sit flush with the rest of the centre console.
Im sure I posted pics of the underside of the ashtray and the small metal wire that holds the lid shut. The wire will have came out of position or be missing.
I cant find the pics anymore on my PC, a lot of pics got ditched and they must have been part of.
If you search the forum for similar the pics will be here somewhere.
Mine can be a bit difficult sometimes as well. I found if you push it closed on one corner (I think the one closest to the passenger seat), rather than in the middle, it shuts a lot more reliably. Not exactly a fix but it might help out in the short term.
I've got the same issue, did you fix yours? I found the metal clip which had fallen out but the plastic bit that holds the clip under tension had also been snapped off. It might not look as nice but I think I'm going to have to replace the whole unit with the lidless storage cubby instead.
It looks like the plastic bit that holds the metal clip in has snapped off, so like ClumUK I have ordered the storage part No.1 as it is a better option for me and the ashtray to replace is more expensive