Interesting to hear everyone’s points... I put my coupe up for sale just after first lockdown... at an overly optimistic price - which people laughed at, and yes it was probably looking for 1k over the going rate but I was only going to sell at above going rate if at all. looking at what’s out there, that my price now looks slightly below market asking price.
But I think the key thing is how much is a Z4C worth to someone.
I’m constantly toying with buying a Z4MC - but the asking price + price running costs feels unjustifiably high compared to Z4C. Double the tax, probably a quarter more in fuel costs, and slightly less boot space (I know!), and from what I’ve heard slightly less fun to daily than a Z4C, plus the potential money pit for high mileage s54 preventative maintenance.
But as with anything it all comes down to the monies.
I’d always have a Z4MC if I could afford it over a Z4C (looks better, the pedigree, the high RPM, and the rarity. However if I had a bit more money, I’d have an M2 over a Z4MC (yes less rare etc, and less special, but as it would be my daily, I could do with having a little bit more convenience day to day. It’d be different if it was a weekend car only.
MC will always be worth more than the coupe, as I’m pretty sure everyone would risk paying a bit more for the pedigree and character, and I do think the MC will eventually become a high value classic, but we probably have another 10–20 years to go before that happens. And naturally when that happens, the Z4C will also go up in price, as it’ll be the slightly cheaper alternative. I guess I can see the 3.0 coupes being in the same ilk as a 911 turbo from the 80s versus 911 carrera. Both cool cars, pretty sure everyone would go for the turbo, but the carrera would always be slightly more accessible.
The only time I can see the Z4C overtaking the Z4M price wise, if all petrol cars got banned, and only electric conversions were allowed... at which point the engine wouldn’t matter, and the extra boot space might become useful.
But let’s hope that never happens