DMC63 said:
Waaaaay too risky. Suction pads holding on a bike frame at 60mph? Are you nuts! I don't care what the marketing schpeel says...The vibrations, change in temp and relative humidity along with forces caused by acceleration and cornering alone stack up to make this a real risk of winding up implanted in someones face along with their windscreen. I just about trust a suction cup to hold my phone to the inside of the screen, and that's fallen off a few times. Jeeeezzzz! They say one thing about common sense is it's not very common. Nothing personal, just my opinion. I'm sure you're a really nice bloke.
Bit harsh DM.
Common sense doesn't really figure in the choice to go with these. I was looking at buying them before I realised it wouldnt work on a roadster but now I'm looking for a coupe aswell I'll def be looking into buying a set if that happens!
My background is design engineering and I would have every confidence in this as a 'pneumatic support mechanism' if used within operating spec. It's actually probably safer in some respects than traditional 'strap-based' bike frames in that it relies on a strong seal to effect pneumatic compression between two already mechanically strong mating surfaces.
Products like these go through insane development and testing regimens before being released to market. No company wants to be held liable for the destruction/damage of 1000's of bikes, ergo they're designed to perform according to a strict design brief, one primary design criteria of which I would presume is 'must not fail by coming loose and destroying bike'.
Suction cups are nothing new and for a bike weighing around or less than 10Kg like mine, with little wind resistance when mounted, I would have no reservations using this whatsoever.
I think a nice 'lux version' development would be some sort of indicator, visual or bluetooth, to warn of any loss of suction. this has 3 mounting points which counts as a 'mechanical system' and hence giving a high degree of failure-redundancy - if 1 mount fails or is compromised then the other 2 take the strain.
Ofc there would be a user-phase of 'is this woking ok?' where you would probably be checking every so often if it's still secure. That's human nature and our own subconcious risk mitigation systems taking over. I'm sure that disappears over time though.
I think it's a well-designed, elegant solution to carrying a bike. A lot less faff than my current heavy strap frame!