I just bought my 2009 35i from a BMW main dealer and I paid £18,220 for it and while I was in the process of buying it the price compared favourably to similar models and at that price I think it is a good deal, it has all of the toys I wanted sat nav/DCT/heated seats etc and it has a one year warranty and only 23,500 miles on it.
I either wanted a 35i or a 35is but I didn't really want to spend any more than 18k as it is a weekend fun car so there weren't any 35is cars at anywhere near that price and I know many of you say the 35is is so much better than the 35i and I don't doubt that

but this 35i is soooooo much better in every way possible than my E85 3.0si and for me the power this 35i has is just amazing so I am more than happy in fact I just adore this car as we took it onto the North york moors yesterday and it felt so brilliant to drive and just be in
As for prices the one Andy posted earlier is a decent deal but with 81,000 miles on it I wouldn't have touched it and that is a main reason for the lower price and the other two he listed were normal 3.0 models and one didn't have sat nav, I didn't check the whole spec on them, another problem when buying used is that finding a 35i or a 35is within your budget and with the colour combination you want is really quite hard as so many are in that metallic blue with white leather and I know it is really popular I just don't like light coloured leather in cars it just says luxury and I want sporty so I got a fab black car with red leather.
As for buying new even with the big discounts you will still be paying around £32,000 for a 35is and in a couple of years that will probably lose another 10k easily and I know I will lose on mine but at just over 18k I won't lose as much as those new cars will lose even with the big discounts.
I don't blame some buying new though as that would be exciting and I would have that lovely Valencia Orange colour

and let's face it life is short and it's only money we can afford our weekend car and are thrilled to bits with it and so looking forward to a week away in the Scottish Highlands in May in our superb roadster, so yes I know it will drop in value as all cars do but I really don't care that much as we will be too busy having fun and making memories

Enjoy your cars whichever model you have
