roof light while driving and roof stuggling to close

gillianb

New member
Hi, the roof light has come on on the dash a couple of times while driving. At the weekend I tested the roof and it dropped with no problem but struggled when closing (but did) - does this sound like a hydraulic fluid is low? Perhaps light going on due to low fluid sensor activating when driving? Would be delighted to hear if anyone has had a similar problem! thanks!
 
I had similar symptoms when battery was not charged enough, it was also quite cold winter days - I just bought the car and had to try opening/closing the hood, then for several days I had not locked alert, till I decided to charge the battery, also the car is in the garage since
 
gillianb said:
Hi, the roof light has come on on the dash a couple of times while driving. At the weekend I tested the roof and it dropped with no problem but struggled when closing (but did) - does this sound like a hydraulic fluid is low? Perhaps light going on due to low fluid sensor activating when driving? Would be delighted to hear if anyone has had a similar problem! thanks!

Hi, the light will come on if you try & activate the roof while going around a bend or over particularly bumpy ground.
Best done on smooth level & straight ground :thumbsup:
Rob
 
that is interesting thanks- it has been very cold off and on lately adn would explain the the difficulties in closing the roof...I wonder if the light coming on once or twice was unrelated...as it really was sporadically while driving along....will check battery
 
Smartbear said:
gillianb said:
Hi, the roof light has come on on the dash a couple of times while driving. At the weekend I tested the roof and it dropped with no problem but struggled when closing (but did) - does this sound like a hydraulic fluid is low? Perhaps light going on due to low fluid sensor activating when driving? Would be delighted to hear if anyone has had a similar problem! thanks!

Hi, the light will come on if you try & activate the roof while going around a bend or over particularly bumpy ground.
Best done on smooth level & straight ground :thumbsup:
Rob

I perhaps should have been clearer - I was just driving along without trying to activate the roof - which is why I wondered if the fluid was low then if might activate a sensor? The only time the roof has been down since the end of summer was to bring a christmas tree home :rofl: who ever said a z4 was not a practical car???
 
gillianb said:
Hi, the roof light has come on on the dash a couple of times while driving. At the weekend I tested the roof and it dropped with no problem but struggled when closing (but did) - does this sound like a hydraulic fluid is low? Perhaps light going on due to low fluid sensor activating when driving? Would be delighted to hear if anyone has had a similar problem! thanks!

Its probably a microswitch.

Don’t mess with hydraulic fluid, as the roof system is very expensive.

If you can figure out at which part its failing on closure, you can use the guides on here to pin point the corresponding switch or sensor.

My guess is a microswitch has failed, as its a common fault.

Replacment at bmw is about £190
 
The switch that has often been replaced was on the rear right boot ram, my problem was a intermittent connector down there.
Seems it has no locking mechanism. Once fully pushed home and cable tied, no more problem.
The switch tells the system the boot is fully open. My problem was as lid stowed in boot, the system would freeze.
I wonder if a break in any switch or cable, as they seem to have a continuity resistor in them throws up a roof light warning.
https://z4-forum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=46&t=106166

I think BMW know it's a known problem as the replacement microswitch is a one part cable and not two parts as they originally came out of the factory.
 
flybobbie said:
The switch that has often been replaced was on the rear right boot ram, my problem was a intermittent connector down there.
Seems it has no locking mechanism. Once fully pushed home and cable tied, no more problem.
The switch tells the system the boot is fully open. My problem was as lid stowed in boot, the system would freeze.
I wonder if a break in any switch or cable, as they seem to have a continuity resistor in them throws up a roof light warning.
https://z4-forum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=46&t=106166

I think BMW know it's a known problem as the replacement microswitch is a one part cable and not two parts as they originally came out of the factory.

I wonder if later e89’s came with the one part cable from new? :?
Rob
 
Back
Top Bottom