I think you give BMW more credit than they deserve on this front. They constantly change the tyres supplied on new models, E46 M3's, E90/92 M3's etc have all been supplied on a wide variation of tyres. Why do you think that is? I believe they take the best deal available from one of the major tyre manufacturer at the time. The fact that all (as far as I know) Z4M's came with Conti's fitted is easily explained by their limited production run at Spartanburg.
The motoring press in general were pretty lukewarm to the Z4M at it's release, not helped by the Conti M3's IMO. Evo magazine, in fact upped their rating of the Z4MC when it was driven again with PS2's.
When the BM3W forum was at it's peak, there was a general consensus that the Conti M3's were a poor tyre choice for the M3. My M3 came with PS2's fitted as standard and it was a late 2003 car, suggesting to me that BMW had realised the folly of persisting with the Conti's which had been fitted at launch (although not exclusively) in 2001.
The newer Conti's, by comparison, have an excellent reputation and would be a good choice when you change Darren.