N52 Oil - Lifter Noise

speed12

Member
Evening all, I am well aware that oil has been talked about a lot on this site, however I am not sure if much has been said about potential impact on reducing engine idle noise/ lifter rattle etc.

My vehicle is still under warranty but it seems to me that this lifter issue will not be sorted by BMW these days and the problem is likely to come back.

I want to do a cheeky mid life oil change (I am aware that if I want to obtain a BMW Mondial Warranty) all Service History should be BMW, however providing I keep a seperate record of my own oil changes how will they know?

Has anyone played around with oil grades? any comments on impact on engine noise?

As far as I am concerned any LL04 oil is fine to use, however whilst the 0W-30 may get to the lifters and other areas sooner it is also more likely to drain away, so I was wondering whether to use a 5W40 LL04 oil? might take longer to drain away and should provide a better barrier than thin oil at temperature?

Any experiences from peoople would be much appreciated.
 
Luckily I've not had any issues with lifter noises. I have been using Shell Helix Ultra Extra for my last two changes.
 
Can't offer any advice I'm afraid, as I have no experience. But I'm interested to hear how you get on as I've had intermittent lifter tick on my 2011 E89. Having scanned the web it seems to be common throughout the BMW range, but it's infrequent on my car and so difficult to take to a dealer and say: "there - sort that".

I have read some other sites where slightly thicker grades of oil have been used to silence the lifters but whether this is a good idea in the long term...I'm not so sure. It seems that the ultimate solution is to complain and complain until BMW take the car in and provide a modified cylinder head (which I thought they had already done for the E89). However, as other owners have noted, if you have your engine messed around with would it ever be the same ? Personally I think I'll live with the ticking although even now, it drives me nuts.

Good luck! :)
 
As long as it's LL04 then BMW cannot complain. Slightly thicker oil may as you say help with the issue. Just stick to a well respected brand.
 
Back
Top Bottom