It was a 'nice' car, but I wouldn't have one even if it was offered in 1:1 trade for my Z4.
It felt more like my old e34 M5 than the e46 M3 - which is either a good or bad thing depending on what you want out of it.
For the few weeks I had one, it was consistently returning less than 20mpg compared to the 28mpg I was getting out of the Z4M on the same runs - including a forum Welsh hoon.
I liked it's grunt over 100mph, but that's when I felt the soft-ish electronic suspension started to let it down and started to feel a bit floaty. At slower speeds the suspension smoothed out the roughness of the UK roads, but it still seemed to take a 'second' to settle itself into the corners before you'd feel confident that it'd gripped. It wasn't understeer, but just a lack of connectivity between the steering wheel & the road, so I found myself turning a fraction earlier to counteract it. It also 'felt' like a very heavy car - which it is when compared to a CSL (which is the only car I'd currently swap/trade my Z4MC for).
In fact I've just seen a high-ish mileage one for sale.Initial hesitation on the throttle was offputting too, although mainly when you were trying to get out in/across a gap in traffic. You'd put your foot down, nothing would happen, you'd put it down more and then realise you weren't going to make the gap...then it would launch and you'd have to slam on!
I think most of the guys on the Welsh tour a while ago heard what I thought of it
