My new policy starts today. Technically, although I'm still with Elephant, it's not a renewal as the renewal quote came to just under £2k! I phoned them up and asked them what planet they were on, as I was expecting it to be around £800 on the basis that (a) I got a quote for about £800 when I was looking for my Z4 back in May (bought in July), (b) I was paying about £330 on my 1.6 focus, and had 3 months left on the policy when I changed to the Z4, which set me back £130 - which roughly works out to £850 for a year. Maybe I had over-simplified it!
Anyway, while they were on the phone, I went to confused.com and elephants own quote came back at £995. Turns out that because I had a non-fault accident just before I bought the Z, I'm now classed as a higher risk. Taking the accident off, it's £800, as expected.
I've just had a word with elephant, they're putting the quote differences into writing for me so I can attempt to claim back the difference from the other party's insurance company, seeing as they assumed liability without much of a fight (the other driver drove into the back of me, in broad daylight, while I was sitting stationary in a queue of traffic. I actually watched her drive into me in the rear view mirror, she was looking everywhere but where she was going! I had nowhere to go - traffic in front and at either side - tapping the brakes to make the lights flash didn't get her attention so I just stood on them and braced for impact! the damage wasn't actually that bad).
Anyway, apologies for going off topic - no significant other to put on the insurance, so got mum on there as an additional named driver (55, driving 20+ years, clean licence no accidents) - cant remember how much it brought it down, but it was a couple of hundred quid at least.