Gearbox mounts

Simon 3.2M

Senior member
I am running vibratechniques engine mounts which are great however, I think the gearbox mounts are a little tired. I've read that most stick with OEM mounts but I was wondering if poly mounts might be more suited and in keeping with the engine ones?

Any advice is much appreciated.
 
I think the advice I got at the time was the gearbox mounts are a worthwhile upgrade on an e46 M3, but not so much on a Z4M as they had different mounts anyway.
 
Simon 3.2M said:
but I was wondering if poly mounts might be more suited and in keeping with the engine ones?

Any advice is much appreciated.
What stiffness poly mounts did you have in mind?
 
GuidoK said:
Simon 3.2M said:
but I was wondering if poly mounts might be more suited and in keeping with the engine ones?

Any advice is much appreciated.
What stiffness poly mounts did you have in mind?

No idea mate as it's something that I have no knowledge of. I'd suspect something only slightly stiffer than OEM, not rock hard or solid mounts.
 
Simon 3.2M said:
No idea mate as it's something that I have no knowledge of. I'd suspect something only slightly stiffer than OEM, not rock hard or solid mounts.

I ask this because the stock mounts are very soft. And then I mean very very very soft.
Think shore 40A or thereabout.
I use probably the simpelest and cheapest upgrade you can think of in this segment, and that is a standard bobbin. You know, a general vibration isolator, which costs usually between £3 and £4 a piece :lol:
06trsteunoudnw.jpg
The curved ones are OEM. The OEM ones look beefier, but because the rubber is so soft, there is no comparison. Those new ones are way stiffer.
But here comes the interesting part: those new ones are Shore55A, which are considerably stiffer than OEM. If you're looking at poly ones, you'll find that they are usually made of shore 80A.
Imho thats way to stiff. The force that the gearbox puts on them is not that much, maybe 20kg or so (if you remove the gearbox mount, you can easily hold it up in the air with 1 hand; the whole assembly more or less balances on the motormounts, not the transmission mounts.

The bobbins I used have as international designation DVA1-40-30-M8-23-55 (thats at least one brand that does it this way, In my country we call it a Type A, but in the UK that seems to mean absolutey nothing)
DVA1 is the type of bobbin: DVA1 means threads at both sides
The next number is the crossection of the rubber part: 40mm
The next number is the hight of the rubber part: 30mm
The next number is the thread size: M8
The next number is the thread lenght: 23mm
And the next number is the rubber stiffness: shore55a (you can also get them in 40A and 70A)
So those are the specs explained

The only thing I had to adapt is to fit a thick washer (2mm) under the bobbin as it's about 2mm shorter than the OEM one (but its impossible to get a 32mm high bobbin, they're all 20 or 30 or 40mm high)

Fitted (here you can see that every aluminium part that comes off my car first gets a trip to the beadblasting cabinet :lol: ):
07transgemonteerd.jpg

Very easy and one of the cheapest mods you can think of.
And if you have doubts if they last: I did this mod 6 years ago, so about 30k miles and I absolutely dont spare my car (except that its garaged)

These bobbins are I guess pretty similar to the Rogue engineering transmission mounts (back then probably the only aftermarket ones available plus some solid ones) but my first thought back then was: I'm not that stupid to pay 60quid or so for a pair of bobbins... :rofl:
 
https://www.zilenz.nl/trillingsdempers/cilindrische-tds/trillingsdemper-type-a
(this is a dutch webshop)
 
Simon 3.2M said:
Don't ship to the UK 😔
I'm sure there is a shop in the UK somewhere that sells bits 'n bobbins... :)

Like here (but I'm sure there are loads others, this is just me doing a random google click )

http://www.wdsltd.co.uk/product/4064/anti-vibration-mounts-male-male-thread-wds-710/
Select 710-403055
It'll cost you a whopping 1,66 ex VAT/piece

Or in stainless:
http://www.wdsltd.co.uk/product/5352/stainless-steel-anti-vibration-mounts-male-male-thread-wds-710/
(select 710-403055A2 at 2,58/piece)

Or even an hourglass shape one if the non OEM look bothers you :lol:
http://www.wdsltd.co.uk/product/4070/anti-vibration-rubber-bobbin-mounts-male-threaded-wds-716/
716-403057

BTW this is quite an easy job to do yourself if you have a diy shop in your area where you can rent a car lift (and you need either a transmission jack or something like an axle stand, to hold up the gearbox).
 
Argenta said:
Why would I change the mounts anyway? If theyre not broken. Engine not exactly wobbly

I think for most it's a 'while you are in there' kind of job. The bolts on my engine mount bracket where it's attached to the hot side of the engine worked loose a couple of years ago and 3 of 4 sheared off - a common problem. The hot side engine mount itself wears faster anyway and needed refreshed, while they were in there and had the engine suspended to do the bolts and the mounts they did the gearbox mounts on mine at the same time. IIRC they just used OEM, but at probably about 60-odd thousand miles it just seemed a sensible thing to do.
 
Argenta said:
Why would I change the mounts anyway? If theyre not broken. Engine not exactly wobbly
You can only experience that if you have driven a similar car but with stiffer engine&gearbox mounts.
The stock stuff isnt exacly wobbly but it's also not exactly firm :D
 
mmm-five said:
I think the advice I got at the time was the gearbox mounts are a worthwhile upgrade on an e46 M3, but not so much on a Z4M as they had different mounts anyway.

How do you actually know when they need changing?
 
R60BBA said:
mmm-five said:
I think the advice I got at the time was the gearbox mounts are a worthwhile upgrade on an e46 M3, but not so much on a Z4M as they had different mounts anyway.
How do you actually know when they need changing?
When you hear a big clonk and the car pops out of gear over the jump in Pflantzgarten 1?
 
mmm-five said:
R60BBA said:
mmm-five said:
I think the advice I got at the time was the gearbox mounts are a worthwhile upgrade on an e46 M3, but not so much on a Z4M as they had different mounts anyway.
How do you actually know when they need changing?
When you hear a big clonk and the car pops out of gear over the jump in Pflantzgarten 1?


:rofl:

...but probably not very funny at all at the time :cry:
 
mmm-five said:
R60BBA said:
mmm-five said:
I think the advice I got at the time was the gearbox mounts are a worthwhile upgrade on an e46 M3, but not so much on a Z4M as they had different mounts anyway.
How do you actually know when they need changing?
When you hear a big clonk and the car pops out of gear over the jump in Pflantzgarten 1?

:rofl: joka.
 
I must say after owning lots of cars none of the drivetrains ever been mounted especially firm to the bodyshell, for obvious reasons.. :)
 
Back
Top Bottom