First Impressions

tintin52

Member
This forum is a great source of information so felt my first impressions might be of interest.
Picked up "new to me" one year old 3.0i sDrive yesterday morning - 3000 miles on clock good colour combination (black & black) and well specified. Bought to replace a Z4 3.0i Sport Coupe so brand is a known quantity. Overall my first impressions are positive - the looks, the ride, the fuel economy, the equipment levels and the overall sense of occasion are all a step up on the old Coupe. Car feels bigger and more grown up although, in my view, the latest Z4 leans more towards GT / sports tourer rather than out and out sports car.
Negatives are lack of storage space, particularly in the boot (which seems to be dominated by "no-go" areas - like I now need to remember not to put anything in the most obvious places) but also in the cabin where until I replaced load-through facility with standard 3 shelf arrangement (which was supplied) there was a distinct lack of useable oddment space. My car has 6 speed sport automatic which I'm hoping will offer best of all worlds, although so far jury is out as I've found driving it in manual mode not entirely intuitive - perhaps in part because I was in habit if short shifting in the manual Coupe both up and down which is not an option with the auto box.
By far biggest negative, however, is the roof mechanism which has been plagued by warning messages every time I've tried to use it. I'm hoping I've just been unlucky but, although selling dealer says it was fully checked for faults in their workshop, less than 6 hours and 200 miles after collecting car its now in the local dealers with a roof that refuses to close. BMW Emergency Assist were very good and immediately identified that I needed to get car under cover at a dealers asap because they acknowledged problem was almost certainly beyond them and rain was threatening. So far I've had red window warning on main console, "Faulty roof latch" message, orange window warning on main console and finally when clam refused to separate "Hydraulic oil too hot" message - and all because I opened the roof to put windbreak in place!
Over last 10 years I've been fortunate to own two Z3s (2.8 and 3.0), a Honda S2000, a Lotus Exige and the Z4 Coupe - and in my opinion Z4 coupe was best all round every-day sports car until now. The Z3s had their limitations, the Honda needed to be driven in v-tech range to be special, the Lotus was very single purpose (namely track based) and last Z4 was pretty good at everything. Before buying latest Z4 I tried a Jaguar XKR (massive performance but also massive), a Nissan 370Z (very exciting but let down by questionable styling, savage fuel economy and totally unacceptable tyre noise), and a Porsche Boxster which had sublime handling and feedback but is just so expensive. Point I'm trying to make is that I'd like to think I'm pretty objective and, provided there are not any ongoing reliability issues, I already feel latest Z4 is up there with best sports cars I've owned or driven although, for obvious reasons, a little concerned that roof mechanism may prove to be the Achilles heel that distracts from an otherwise excellent sports car ownership experience.
 
Could it be that's why it was for sale to you? Car returned by owner as roof faulty? I've not had any major faults on mine just a couple of minor niggles (lights full of water)
 
Welcome to rare 3.0 sdrive Z4 club :D

The only problems I have encountered thus far in 15 months and 34,000 miles is a squeaky roof, which the stealer has fixed. Just a fantastic, practical car to own and as far as I am concerned the boot is pretty good even with the top down and positively generous with it up, but hey if you wanted a big boot you should have bought a Volvo V70 :)
 
Thanks for encouraging feedback about reliability.
Mine's an ex BMW management car so I'm leaning more towards something having gone wrong while it’s been standing about for a few weeks - and I've noticed from this Forum that mine isn't the only ex BMW car to have suffered a roof fault.
As for boot space, I'm not saying there isn't enough space only there aren't many places to keep oddments in boot area and already concluded that what can't find a home in the cabin or in the boot under floor box will just have to go rather than risk anything straying into the areas which would impede the roof retracting.
Once I know what's caused current roof problem will post again.
 
Hi,
I'm on my second Z4 in two months (new style) the first was plagued with roof problems. It kept jamming or saying it was up when it wasn't and vice versa. This also locked the boot and caused me a headache as the chime wouldn't turn off...

So the dealer took it in, fixed it and returned it. Except, it wasn't fixed....

Long story short, they gave me a replacement car which has been as good as gold.

I've the 23i blue with ivory pack and pretty much (save for DAB radio and heated steering wheel) fully spec'd... It's my first sports car and I am loving it.

I hope the roof issues are resolved soon for you.

JK
 
Ps my issues were apparently hydraulic boot sensors failing. Of which, I am told there are many in the boot.
 
That's not quite so encouraging JK especially as symtoms sound all too familiar. On plus side however pressure is all on BMW to resolve this under their Approved Used Committment.
 
Ex BMW managers car owner here also. No problems so far in 20,000 miles. I'm sure once it's fixed you'll be pleased with ownership. Always a downer mind when things like this happen when you have looked forward to owning a car! I had problems with my first BMW made MINI! That many faults they took it back after 7 months and built me a new one!! FOC!
 
Just heard from Elms who seem very confident they've located problem - a faulty microswitch. Expecting to get car back later today with fully operational and reliable roof and a boot that unlocks consistently. Here's hoping....
 
tintin - My roof has been perfect since I bought the car :poke:

As to the 'limited storage' please see http://www.z4-forum.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=23&t=14229&p=210588#p210588 :o
 
Good news and bad. Good news is that after replacing faulty microswitch roof now opens perfectly every time - bad news is there's still an intermittent fault whereby it will sometimes still refuse to close correctly. Staying with Elms another day while they track down cause of ongoing problem.
Encouraged to hear most experiences with roof positive - and seriously impressed with what MikeS can get in his boot.
 
Well after 2 days at Elms the roof does now seems to be working perfectly - no permanently locked boot, no "dancing windows", no error messages / chimes and best of all no roof getting stuck half closed. Not sure exactly what was done but noticed the technician had filled in 3 complete work cards and solution involved dismantling and reassembling a considerable section of the boot.
With roof working ok, once again feeling positive about new car, even though current possession score is me 12 hours, dealer 49 hours :x . Still not really mastered paddle shifts but at least I've managed to install some music and a couple of European itineraries from a USB stick and found another oddment storage bin on driver's side :)
Latest issue, though, is that car has virtually no ground clearance because the plastic skid tray under car seems to be distorted downwards on rear edge and is grounding when I reverse into drive - can't believe this is right because old Z4 Coupe had no problems and even the Exige with its ultra-low splitter never grounded getting in and out of my driveway. Ground clearance at lowest point seems to be about 100mm which a lot less than claimed clearance of 124mm. Be interested to know if anyone else's skid tray sits 1.0"-1.5 " below rest of underside. At moment, looks like I'll be back to Elms tomorrow to get their opinion.
 
Back
Top Bottom