Okay, it's taken quite some time for me to get the kinks worked out of my ESS S/C install
http://esstuning.com/ess-n52-vt1-supercharger-system-gen-2/ and get her making the kind of power they advertise. This, I think is primarily due to the fact they've never had an install of the S/C kit on a 2009+ N52 Z4. At least that's the way it appears based on the communications I've had with them, the additional parts and ECU tunes they've had to send me, etc. After a few trips to the dyno and trying to work things out long distance with them, I finally got smart and decided to take the car to a local (relatively) BMW performance shop and have them tune it. Bimmer Perfomance Center
https://bimmerperformancecenter.com/ in Raleigh, NC did the tuning for me yesterday. These guys know how to pull power out of a BMW. Bob Bishop spent the whole day with the car tuning, tuning it, and re-tuning it and now it finally makes the power I expected when I bought the S/C kit and installed it. The image shows the baseline power she was producing (with the S/C installed) and then the final power. Note I'm now getting 291 wheel HP and 241 wheel torque after a proper tuning. This is an increase of 83 whp and 44 wtq over stock. Pretty impressive.
The kit originally came with a 120mm blower pulley but I had them send me the 115mm pulley. I also have upgraded injectors and the 3 stage intake on my car. I think one of the issues I had with the ESS tunes is they assumed I had the single stage intake so they weren't tuning to take advantage of the 3 stage. Their tunes also did some funky things to my shift points and the last tune they sent me disabled my tach and made my MPG calculations way off. BPC has fixed all that and I can't say enough good things about them. They're my BMW shop from now on even though they're 2 1/2 drive away from me. My next step will be to add methanol injection. BPC said I could expect another 20-30 whp by adding the methanol. It looks like a pretty easy add and I'll provide another update after that's done. That will also help if I want to increase boost (now running about 7 psi, BPC said I could safely go to 10-14 psi with stock internals) which would really add some power to the beast. They think we can safely go to 400 whp and still maintain longevity.
For now, I can't wait to get this thing on a track where I can get some perf measurements!