DCT paddle orientation and throttle options.

breezer

Member
I’m looking for a 35i, as I’m after a cruiser that’s still fun. I’ve come from a Z4MC, which was excellent in many ways, but uncomfortable, expensive, and largely pointless given the quality of U.K. roads. I also really disliked the adaptive throttle - coming off a motorway it would require huge travel to blip the throttle at all to downchange into a roundabout, but after a few miles of spirited B roads, the slightest throttle travel would add 3k rpm! This made downshifts a guessing game: how much travel will be required to rev match this time - who knows?! I love to heel-toe all day long in my Tuscan (an actual cable throttle!), but the Z4MC was inconsistent and frankly unpleasant.

Thus the DCT sounds good, and whilst I’d generally prefer a manual, I don’t like manuals with non-linear throttle maps for the above reasons.

So I have two sets of questions and would be really grateful for some guidance:

1) I’ve heard there are multiple throttle settings available. Was this an option or is it standard on the 35i without the M Sport suspension? If it exists, is a linear, non-adaptive map an option?

2) I’ve read reviews saying the DCT paddles operate weirdly - pull towards you for downshift and push away for upshift? Is this true? I used to have an E39 that shifted that same way, but my more recent E92 shifts the ‘correct’ way (pull to upshift, push to downshift) so I really hoped BMW had learned that the former is a counter intuitive direction of movement....

In the E39 there was a simple way to reverse the direction - is that the case on the E89?

I’m honestly not sure I could live with the reverse paddles, so would wait for a good manual to come along if nothing can be done.

Many thanks!
 
Thus the DCT sounds good, and whilst I’d generally prefer a manual, I don’t like manuals with non-linear throttle maps for the above reasons.
If I remember correctly, when flashing via MHD it has the option for a "linear throttle map"
 
sunnydays said:
Thus the DCT sounds good, and whilst I’d generally prefer a manual, I don’t like manuals with non-linear throttle maps for the above reasons.
If I remember correctly, when flashing via MHD it has the option for a "linear throttle map"

Thanks! Also, curse you for sending me down that rabbit hole. I’m now left wondering about an improved intercooler and a stage 1 + FMIC setup before I’ve even been to test an e89! :rofl:
 
On the later cars I'm sure the paddles got changed to the other way round , and I'm sure some on here have done the swap/upgrade
 
On the facelift models the paddles reverted to the more conventional LH paddle pull to downchange and RH paddle pull to upchange as the majority of the other manufacturers do. :thumbsup:
 
eff1guy said:
On the facelift models the paddles reverted to the more conventional LH paddle pull to downchange and RH paddle pull to upchange as the majority of the other manufacturers do. :thumbsup:

Are you sure that happened on the face lift? Mine is a 2012 and that is what I have
 
Hunter said:
eff1guy said:
On the facelift models the paddles reverted to the more conventional LH paddle pull to downchange and RH paddle pull to upchange as the majority of the other manufacturers do. :thumbsup:

Are you sure that happened on the face lift? Mine is a 2012 and that is what I have

Are they pull for up and push for down? Or the other way round?
 
Hunter said:
Are you sure that happened on the face lift? Mine is a 2012 and that is what I have
Ooh, not sure. I just presumed it was on the facelifts :oops: Which indicators do you have on the front wings, the old version or the facelift??

breezer said:
Are they pull for up and push for down? Or the other way round?

Just pull only not like the older version you are talking about which did both. Left paddle pull to come down gears, right paddle pull to change up the box.
 
Being able to pull for up & push for down with either hand is a big advantage.

On my 911, finding the pull left for down and the pull right for up when the wheel was whipping round at high speed on a bendy road wasn't anywhere near as good.
 
eff1guy said:
Hunter said:
Are you sure that happened on the face lift? Mine is a 2012 and that is what I have
Ooh, not sure. I just presumed it was on the facelifts :oops: Which indicators do you have on the front wings, the old version or the facelift??

breezer said:
Are they pull for up and push for down? Or the other way round?

Just pull only not like the older version you are talking about which did both. Left paddle pull to come down gears, right paddle pull to change up the box.

What is the difference in the indicators?
 
Hunter said:
eff1guy said:
Hunter said:
Are you sure that happened on the face lift? Mine is a 2012 and that is what I have
Ooh, not sure. I just presumed it was on the facelifts :oops: Which indicators do you have on the front wings, the old version or the facelift??

breezer said:
Are they pull for up and push for down? Or the other way round?

Just pull only not like the older version you are talking about which did both. Left paddle pull to come down gears, right paddle pull to change up the box.

Just checked, mine are the non LED white plastic thingys
 
Hunter said:
Just checked, mine are the non LED white plastic thingys

Ok, so those are the pre-facelift indicators. They must have changed the gearbox paddles and presumably then the gear lever too before the facelift. My apologies, I just thought it was a facelift thing :thumbsup:
 
My 59 reg 35i DCT is pull for upshifts and push for downshifts. Both paddles are the same. I like it that way, not having to find the correct paddle.
 
My previous E89 3.0l was like that - I also thought it was ok,

Big button = Big gear / Little button =Little gear :rofl:
 
Back
Top Bottom