Carol M said:
dan425 said:Carol M said:
I missed that one. Was there a thread?

there you go carol when you are ready for an M you can do a swap with ruby ,.. everyone happy , until then enjoy the new Porsche, by the way definitely not a poor mans porche but built to fill a specific gap in the Stuttgart lineup, streets ahead of the other roadsters around, mx5, s2000, mr2 , mg but aimed at a less performance / price point market than 9 the 911.Carol M said:It's horses for courses.
The Porsche seems to pip the zed on most reviews (but only just by a half or one star).
From my point of view after owning both, I prefer the porsche. I can't comment on performance as my zed was a 2.0, the porsche is a 3.4. No comparison.
Just a couple of observations that helps my preference are the looks, beautiful classic sports car styling.
Getting in and out is waaaay easier. The door on the porsche is set further forward so you are not swinging your legs out on the narrow part of the opening.
The computer/sat nav is touch screen with surrounding buttons to control and also controls on the steering wheel so you have 3 different ways to use it but it's not cluttered at all.
Dash clocks - normal with a digital readout as well also the sat nav shows next move on the clock as well as the screen.
Cup holders!! Proper ones!!
Bags more storage in the front and rear boots.
Handling, even in this wet I can feel the difference. It's going to blow the zed out of the water on dry, summer roads.
Just a few observations off the top of my head but saying that, I'd have a zed again in a heartbeat, preferably bigger engine than the one I had. Good luck!
Paza3 said:Awesome cars loved mine and a more accomplished car than the Z4MC I have also owned (+ 3 Other Z4's)
It will feel much more of a sports car then a 35i , although a DCT 35si could not be ignored. The Zed will also feel more modern inside and have a awesome roofing system and is tbh hard to compare to a Cayman which is a drivers car in comparison . I honestly think my Cayman handles better than the 911's I have owned a really great car. I would seriously consider a Gen 2 so 2009 on-wards even the 2.9 if you can, as it has the DFI engine which is more reliable, sadly there is a failure rate on early models this cannot be ignored, but fitting a LTT , proper servicing , proper maintenance and driving you should be fine on a Gen 1 car. Also a lot of Zed owners have moved to Caymans, nothing like seeing Stuttgart's Finest on the drive or in the garage![]()
mcbeee said:nothing looks more classic than a Z3MR with the top down (silk scarf optional)![]()
![]()
seg said:Paza3 said:Awesome cars loved mine and a more accomplished car than the Z4MC I have also owned (+ 3 Other Z4's)
It will feel much more of a sports car then a 35i , although a DCT 35si could not be ignored. The Zed will also feel more modern inside and have a awesome roofing system and is tbh hard to compare to a Cayman which is a drivers car in comparison . I honestly think my Cayman handles better than the 911's I have owned a really great car. I would seriously consider a Gen 2 so 2009 on-wards even the 2.9 if you can, as it has the DFI engine which is more reliable, sadly there is a failure rate on early models this cannot be ignored, but fitting a LTT , proper servicing , proper maintenance and driving you should be fine on a Gen 1 car. Also a lot of Zed owners have moved to Caymans, nothing like seeing Stuttgart's Finest on the drive or in the garage![]()
Are you sure about the DFI engine in the base cayman gen 2? I thought only the cayman S gen 2 had DFI? The current cayman (2013) both (base and S) have DFI.
mcbeee said:I have heard of an RS version of a Cayman , limited numbers built in one year only. Not sure if it's true or not..... nice if it was![]()
As mentioned above by Paza, the Cayman (and the Boxster) do outhandle the 911.![]()
Paza3 said:seg said:Paza3 said:Awesome cars loved mine and a more accomplished car than the Z4MC I have also owned (+ 3 Other Z4's)
It will feel much more of a sports car then a 35i , although a DCT 35si could not be ignored. The Zed will also feel more modern inside and have a awesome roofing system and is tbh hard to compare to a Cayman which is a drivers car in comparison . I honestly think my Cayman handles better than the 911's I have owned a really great car. I would seriously consider a Gen 2 so 2009 on-wards even the 2.9 if you can, as it has the DFI engine which is more reliable, sadly there is a failure rate on early models this cannot be ignored, but fitting a LTT , proper servicing , proper maintenance and driving you should be fine on a Gen 1 car. Also a lot of Zed owners have moved to Caymans, nothing like seeing Stuttgart's Finest on the drive or in the garage![]()
Are you sure about the DFI engine in the base cayman gen 2? I thought only the cayman S gen 2 had DFI? The current cayman (2013) both (base and S) have DFI.
Seems were both part right , it's fitted with new 9A1 architecture (as are the DFI motors), so you get a stronger platform with better oiling that does not suffer from RMS leaks and cylinder chunking. So not quite the full 3.4s dfi but pretty much![]()
chester2000 said:Thanks for all the comments.
After viewing the main contender yesterday I have reached the decision to continue my quest for a 35i.
The Cayman was a great car but certainly lacked refinement. I think the fact your practically sat on the engine didn't help it's cause nor did the fact I could fit my golf equipment in![]()
It may seem to some very harsh ruling a car out because it didn't accommodate my golf equipment but this was a major consideration when I opted for my first Zed a few years ago....I ruled out my ex girlfriend for not accommodating golf too![]()
Anyway thanks again...I still looking for a 35i if anyone wants to get rid of theirs![]()
chester2000 said:Yes..Thanks
I think for a non M sport that was overpriced. I called yesterday and they didn't call back !!
There's another one that I'm trying to beat up on price as it's £3k over budget.
Bluestreak56 - The XK coupe is a great looking car but I've just sold an XK convertible to go back to a Zed. Cracking car but it doesn't "hug" you like a Zed does.
chester2000 said:The one I'm looking at is the Gen 1, but has the balance of the warranty (1 year). Oh and has the ceramic brakes too![]()
GBG said:chester2000 said:The one I'm looking at is the Gen 1, but has the balance of the warranty (1 year). Oh and has the ceramic brakes too![]()
I'd stay well clear of that car if I was you, ceramic brakes are fitted when the original owner wanted to track the car a lot :thumbsdown: