Broken bumper - NEED ADVICE - Please help?

River32

Member
Hi everyone, I need help!

This is my first post on here so Hi! I own a Grey 2007 Z4 2.5si - I pulled forward from a parking space and incorrectly assumed that my space was like all the others in view - connected. (i.e. nothing to stop me pulling from one space to the opposite one)

SO, I've pulled forward and heard a CRUNCH. Totally unaware of there being a hidden, and might I add, pointless curb I reversed at the same slow speed of 2-3 mph and heard further crunching. I got out to inspect the sounds and I had found that I've pulled the driver's side of the front bumper off!! The plastic on the underside has broken, and the teeth that clip the bumper to the plastic have snapped. The bracket that secures the bumper cover in place (near the wheel arch) has snapped clean off also.

I didn't get anywhere near far enough to the curb to touch the wheels, and it was not an impact that in my mind should warrant significant damage to the car/chassis.

I would appreciate help and advice on what to do next, and whether the initial quote of £1700 is fair and likely to be accurate? I personally think the price is ridiculous. What do you guys think?

I have broken down and listed the initial estimate of the repair below:

-- The Quote --

"To remove the front bumper, front undertrays and o/s/f archliner. Prepare, prime and spray new front bumper cover. Refit bumper, undertrays and archliner using new parts as listed"

Bodyshop labour 8hrs @ £34 per hr = £272.00
Paint & materials = £198.56
Car care kit = £3.50
EPA charge = £3.50
Front bumper cover = £391.62
Front bumper grill = £61.92
o/s/f bumper bracket = £24.31
Impact damper = £23.67
o/s/f inner extension bracket = £11.56
o/s/f arch liner = £91.56
front center undertray = £94.25
o/s/f/ undertray extension = £122.42
Undertray fittings = £12.36
Sundries = £15.20
4-wheel steering alignment check = £75.00 - *Not having this done as a waste of money*
-------------
Subtotal = £1,401.43
-------------
VAT Total = £280.29
-------------
Total = £1681.72
-------------
 
Get some pics up.... But wont be more than a couple of hundred to repaint the lower section and replace the lower platics diy.
 
:lol: What a load of rubbish.

If you've done damage to the plastic arch liners, you can get replacements for £100 new from BMW. Other plastic bits can be repaired if need be. Get a second hand bumper off eBay. I wouldn't expect to pay any more than £500 for everything.

In future, always reverse into spaces like that. I've done exactly what you did and got away with snapped bumper brackets. They cost £25 each.
 
ben g said:
:lol: What a load of rubbish.

If you've done damage to the plastic arch liners, you can get replacements for £100 new from BMW. Other plastic bits can be repaired if need be. Get a second hand bumper off eBay. I wouldn't expect to pay any more than £500 for everything.

In future, always reverse into spaces like that. I've done exactly what you did and got away with snapped bumper brackets. They cost £25 each.

What Ben said. Stick a picture up.
 
Clearly the price is ridiculous and they have just added on for every possible item at the front end, which assuming your description of speed and impact is correct, does not seem warranted.

I'd like to see photos (as others have indicated) of the side where the bumper came off, the brackets and the points of impact to assist in diagnosis.

Upload photos to photobucket, Flickr, etc. click on IMG in the posting window and then just paste their URL location in there.

As an aside your error was to simply drag it back over the kerb without getting out, examining it, and working out how to get clear, etc. Most damage is done dragging the bumper off the kerb.
 
From the sound of it, the absolute worst case is a new bumper, sprayed and fitted with the plastic clip between the front wing and bumper.

Brand new bumper: £400 roughly
2nd hand bumper: £150 tops?
Sprayed: £200 tops (could get a 2nd hand bumper in the same colour)
Clip: £20
Fitting: 15 minute job yourself

Minimum: £150
Max: £650

Almost definately will not have damaged the under tray parts from what youre saying, but even then they come to a max of £150 brand new and considerably less 2nd hand (which doesnt matter as theyre not seen)
 
<a href="http://s1377.photobucket.com/user/River_Filmer/media/BMW%20Z4/BMW%20Z4%201_zpszpcwshys.jpeg.html" target="_blank"><img

Just a test to see if I'm understanding HTML photo stuff.

EDIT CJ10 - I linked it correctly for you so you can see what to do:
BMW%20Z4%201_zpszpcwshys.jpeg
 
Thanks guys for all of your help so far!

I'm going to take some pictures today and post them to my Photobucket account. I'll link you all on here.

The car atm is taped up to be safe to drive around. I'll do my best.
 
cj10jeeper said:
See above where I've dropped in the image for you.

Nice looking zed (well before you damaged it :) )


Thanks :)

I have now worked it out! I'll show you the situation of the car park - I have a picture.
 
Right everyone - I have news! From £1700 to £700:

I went to a small body and alloy specialist today and he looked at it for less than five minutes and said I DO NOT need a new bumper OR a new lower mesh.

He told me to source the parts myself via online or BMW, and he would fit them + refurb the mark on the underside and repaint to a nice finish. Cost = £250.

I phoned BMW to see the worst case scenario price of parts and it is looking like £400-£450 max.

1 x Complete undertray
1 x Main archliner
1 x Lower archliner
1 x Wheel-arch wing bracket
5 x Rivets
1 x Fixings/nuts and bolts to fit plastics

Any tips of where to search for the above parts at lower prices?

Thanks!
 
Bracket, rivetts and nuts I'd buy from BMW, cheap enough and may as well go new.

Undertray and liners, look on eBay for "BMW z4 braking", find one local and call them to check parts
 
Liam-O said:
Bracket, rivetts and nuts I'd buy from BMW, cheap enough and may as well go new.

Undertray and liners, look on eBay for "BMW z4 braking", find one local and call them to check parts


Thanks a lot for the help :)
 
No worries, although I've just realised i meant "BMW Z4 breaking", braking will find you different parts ;)
 
Back
Top Bottom