BMW Z4M Coupe with couple "issues"

Nolwyn

Member
 Belgium
Hello!

I'm the proud owner of a Z4M Coupe. The car has been originally sold in France for his first owner, and my dad bought it in 2016 at around 50 000kms. My dad passed away in 2021 and I managed to keep his car even if he was in financial trouble at the end of his life, that's basically all that's left of him to me, and it costed me some money haha (had to sell my E34 M5 3.6).

I managed to get the car back in summer 2023 at 98 000kms where it didn't run for like 2-3 years. I did all fluids to the car, and last year I did some bodywork needed and the famous rod bearings by a shop.

Just a headsup: I'm someone we could call "oversensitive" and the equivalent of "hypochondriac" but with cars. Any noise or thingy that doesn't sound "normal" makes me sweat and wonder what's wrong with the car.
A few months ago I went to the Nürburgring for the first time and found the brakes pretty bad. They didn't last a single lap and even when letting them cool down before goind to a next one, they felt like a s**t. I KNOW for a fact that the stock brakes are bad but didn't expect THAT MUCH. It was at the point that my brake fluid boiled and air got in into the system. There was definitely some pumping needed when I got back so I decided to not touch the car until I bled the brakes properly.

One month ago, I went to my usual mechanic to have the brakes bled with swapping the brake hoses with Goodridge solid ones. To my surprise, there was already some kind of noname performance solid brake hoses but they seemed at least 10 years old so I figured out to replace them anyway. We then bled the brakes with RBF600 and using the BMW procedure for the ABS module with ISTA-D. Lots of air bubbles came out. After that the braking feel was much better (no more pumping) BUT still unsatisfactory. I mean that the pedal still felt soft, with a slight "almost no brake" travel before really bitting.
I then went on a shop that I KNOW is trustworthy, they do motorsports and are specialized on BMW and M vehicles to do a new brake bleeding procedure, again with ABS pump etc. They told there was almost no air in the system when they bled the brakes but... still the same for me. There's still this kind of "soft" feel and pedal travel that are not okay for me. I drive a 415 000kms E46 as a daily driver with regular brake fluid that hasn't been changed in 2 years and the pedal feels WAY BETTER.

I've read on this forum, and many other forums that the brake feel on the Z4M is s**t, but I don't remember it being THAT bad when I first got the car. Or maybe it's just me that never really noticed it in the past and now that I'm used to drive the car fast, it's bothering me... I don't really know.
I don't want really want to go into expensive parts replacement without a proper explanation of what can cause this... I'm okay with replacing the brakes for 4 pistons etc but I wont to make sur it will get rid of this brake feel first.

My second point is that I've noticed that sometimes (it's intermittent), when driving very slow corner or just parking, the direction is noisy, like some kind of whining. It's never the case cold, and SOMETIMES when the car is hot. It's very subtle but can't find the cause...

Sorry for my long message, hope you enjoy reading :D
 
Try different brake pads and maybe rebuild the calipers. I'm big on brake feel and am happy with my standard brakes. If working properly there should be no 'dead' travel and there will be lots of feel and modulation. If you're spending a lot of time on track then an upgrade is justified, but for the road standard brakes with good pads and fluid are all you'll ever need.

Regarding the steering whine, try draining and replacing the power-steering fluid.
 
plenty said:
Try different brake pads. I'm big on brake feel and am happy with my standard brakes. If working properly there should be no 'dead' travel and there will be lots of feel and modulation. If you're spending a lot of time on track then an upgrade is justified, but for the road standard brakes with good pads and fluid are all you'll ever need.

Regarding the steering whine, try draining and replacing the power-steering fluid.

Hello!

Thanks for your reply! :D
I'm not going to the track often just some spirited driving, that's why upgrading the whole brake system is can be avoided, is preferable. For brake pads, I use standard Brembo ones but I know that Brembo have had some shitty feedback recently regarding quality. I've also thought that it might be the pistons retracting too much + used brake pads that could be the cause.

For the steering, thanks. I thought of doing that as first tentative of "fixing" it. Just wanted to check if others had a similar noise :p

Thanks!
 
Just my view on the brakes. I think my stock Z4M Roadie brakes are very good for the road. I love the feel and modulation they have.
As said it sounds like pads being the issue to me.
 
Welcome to the forum. :thumbsup:

You must be pleased you managed to keep your dad's car, even if it came at a cost.

I've never found the brakes on my MC to be lacking, but then I've never hammered it around a track. But even on some pretty spirited Z4 runs they have been fine. Good luck getting yours how you want them.
 
Nolwyn said:
I've also thought that it might be the pistons retracting too much + used brake pads that could be the cause.
There is nothing mechanical or hydraulic that 'retracts' brake pistons. You simply remove the pressure applied to them and the action of the revolving disc moves the pads back sufficiently to allow free movement.
 
Another vote for pads - had similar issues in my 3.0si with soft pedal feel when I installed Greenstuff Pads. Then had the opposite problem in my M, where the brake pedal was effectively a switch when hot (and also judder from the pad compound depositing itself on the disc) running OEM ATe pads.

Both problems fixed with different pads.

Regarding your other issue, could be the standard groaning some E46 M3 diffs can get due to the friction plates in the LSD. Oil change and friction modifiers may help - plenty of discussion on this on the M3Cutters forum.
 
lucasxdiniz said:
Regarding your other issue, could be the standard groaning some E46 M3 diffs can get due to the friction plates in the LSD. Oil change and friction modifiers may help - plenty of discussion on this on the M3Cutters forum.

Hey, thanks! I know this issue and mine had it, fixed it by using the correct oil with additives. The noise is defintely coming from the steering.

Kind regards
 
Nolwyn said:
Hey, thanks! I know this issue and mine had it, fixed it by using the correct oil with additives. The noise is defintely coming from the steering.

Kind regards

Ah, sorry, I may have misread your original post. Mine does the standard power-steering groan when I am in full lock, but other than that I don't know anything. Will be replacing the fluid this coming month, if that helpsn, I'll post here for posterity.
 
lucasxdiniz said:
Nolwyn said:
Hey, thanks! I know this issue and mine had it, fixed it by using the correct oil with additives. The noise is defintely coming from the steering.

Kind regards

Ah, sorry, I may have misread your original post. Mine does the standard power-steering groan when I am in full lock, but other than that I don't know anything. Will be replacing the fluid this coming month, if that helpsn, I'll post here for posterity.

No problem!

Thanks everyone for the infos. I will be looking to replace my steering fluid and my brake pads!

I will let you know if it helped with the issue.
 
My brakes are an inconsistent mystery.

I’ve had them bled and they’ve stayed a bit soft.
I’ve had them bled and they’ve been over sensitive.
I’ve had an MOT and they sharpened up.
I’ve changed pads and noticed no difference.
I’ve used them hard and they’ve gotsharper.
I’ve used them hard and nothing changes.
:lol:

Feckin’ car has a mind of its own!
 
beanie said:
My brakes are an inconsistent mystery.

I’ve had them bled and they’ve stayed a bit soft.
I’ve had them bled and they’ve been over sensitive.
I’ve had an MOT and they sharpened up.
I’ve changed pads and noticed no difference.
I’ve used them hard and they’ve stayed get sharper.
I’ve used them hard and nothing changes.
:lol:

Feckin’ car has a mind of its own!

I totally agree with you. I've read on this forum and several other forums people calling out this behaviour depsite having fine pads/discs/brake booster etc. Some people also with totally stock brakes have no isse at all with a very firm pedal and no issue.
In my case I've noticed that sometimes my brake feel is good, and sometimes it's really s**t, even both during a 10 minutes drive depending on the speed I'm at, etc...

Kinda reassuring I'm not the only one having this, because the second shop checked the braking system and couldn't find anything wrong with it...
 
Ive just learnt to accept it for what it is. Generally, no matter what change I notice, it’s largely temporary and always seems to revert to a slightly soft, longer travel pedal that lacks feel and modulation. They work well though so I’ve no intention to throw money at the issue!

I haven’t experienced inconsistency within a short period though, I wonder if that could be activation of the emergency brake assist or related to its vacuum circuit? I think there’s a shutoff valve between the airbox and servo and that can cause rough running if it blocks up.

I’ve also had similar experiences when bleeding the clutch. The shifts will be ultra slick and easy for a while, but will eventually revert to requiring more care and attention than any other car. I supposedly had the slave cylinder changed but there was zero difference in shift feel so I doubt the guy did the work :x

All this leads me to think it’s a vacuum issue, but as it seems to settle to an ok baseline, I’m just leaving it. Perhaps when the next service comes around I’ll see if the system can be tested for leaks, if that’s even a thing?!
 
lucasxdiniz said:
Another vote for pads - had similar issues in my 3.0si with soft pedal feel when I installed Greenstuff Pads. Then had the opposite problem in my M, where the brake pedal was effectively a switch when hot (and also judder from the pad compound depositing itself on the disc) running OEM ATe pads.

Both problems fixed with different pads.

Hello again,

I'm going to have a look at my pads today and see what they're at. I'm thinking about swapping them in the coming days/weeks.

What pads did you run in the end to have a good feel?
 
Nolwyn said:
Hello again,

I'm going to have a look at my pads today and see what they're at. I'm thinking about swapping them in the coming days/weeks.

What pads did you run in the end to have a good feel?

YellowStuff Pads felt amazing in my 3.0si and in a mate's RX8, so I'd say they're the best feel I've had in terms of pedal firmness and modulation. I am currently running RedStuff pads in the M; they feel very good, but they're not as good as Yellows on the modulation side as they're more on the firmer side.
 
lucasxdiniz said:
YellowStuff Pads felt amazing in my 3.0si and in a mate's RX8, so I'd say they're the best feel I've had in terms of pedal firmness and modulation. I am currently running RedStuff pads in the M; they feel very good, but they're not as good as Yellows on the modulation side as they're more on the firmer side.

Okay thanks! I was more looking on going Ferodo or Pagid as EBC brakes in Belgium are very expensive thanks to Brexit.
I've done oil change + transmission fluid today and I know it's not relevant to the topic but it made the gearbox feel 100x times betters, especially 1st-2nd-3rd that were sometimes a pain in the ass.

Regarding the brakes, I checked and my ATE pads (I guess OEMs but from Autodoc) look fine. They are wearing smooth and flat in contact to the disk. I did a little more test drive regarding the brakes afterwards and I've noticed something: when going on a full stop or just moving the car in a parking lot, I can pump "once" the brakes and the pedal seems much firmer. Like if I brake from let's say 5km/h and stop, I can pump the pedal tot he floor and when it comes back, it's much harder.

I don't need to pump when braking hard, and I'm 99.99% sure there's no more air in the system after the last 2 mechanics took care of it. Maybe it's something normal, I've never noticed this behaviour on my E46 or any other car I had in the past.
 
Back
Top Bottom