Hi,
I've also had a 997 C2S so can help there too.
997T vs. 35i
——————
#1 reason is that i missed having a convertible. i bought an S2000 as i’d never owned one, but missed the mod cons so bought the Z4.
yup OG spot on. 997T exhaust note is non-existent. will cost about £3K to get it decent. love the pops and burbles from the 35i exhaust.
difficult to drive the 997T slowly. it only comes alive at crazy speeds, which you get to within seconds. i rarely drive fast these days and the Z4 just wants to cruise along. it’s no sports car.
the handling on both a 997 C2S and 997T blows away the Z4. i haven’t driven a Z4 with adaptive suspension, but can’t imagine it will help that much.
2007 997T vs. 2009 Z4. Z4 has better sat nav, iPod integration and bluetooth, i.e. has newer tech.
slush box 997T vs. DCT Z4. obviously the DCT is a better gearbox.
running costs for the C2S and turbo aren’t scary if you use an indie and are comparable to a high end bmw. if you use Porsche and BMW dealers then there will be a big difference between the two.
My 997 is pristine. i’m often worried about muppets going into it whilst driving and where i should park it. not bothered about the Z4.
you can put a Porsche warranty on a used car even if you buy it privately, but it is very restrictive. i.e. no mods. dealer servicing only (a bit of a grey area).
a £45K 997T will be old, but will be a top of the range car with loads of toys. A £32K 35i will have very few toys and i’m sure will get to over £40K by the time you’ve picked some “essential” options.
997T vs. 997 C2S
—————————
Even though the 997T is not supposed to have any turbo lag there is a definite point where the power kicks in. i’m going to stick to NA cars in the future.
the C2S feels more spritely than the turbo. i’d say the C2S was more of a sports car whilst the turbo is more of a grand tourer. i used to the track the C2S. don’t think the turbo would be as much fun.
i can no longer drive manual cars because of back issues. the turbo is the only model where you can get away with a slush box auto. non-T cars need to be manual (my 997 C2S was) or PDK.
i find the styling of non-T 997s a bit bland. i love the side intakes on the turbo.
interior on both models is the same. the 99T comes with more toys. you have to get sports chrono as it gives you a sport mode that reduces the traction control and also gives 10 secs of overboost.
again there’s not much difference maintaining a C2S vs. a turbo as long as you use an indie.
----------------
Blimey i had a lot to say. in conclusion.....
if i had £45K-£50K to spend on either a 997 or a 35iS i'd go for a gen 2 997 C4S (wider body than C2S) Targa with PDK. i think that's how much they'd cost.