£612 for an oil service? I think not

AldridgeZ4

Member
 Walsall
I was going to keep my service history full BMW, but at £612 for an oil service at Sytner, I don't think so. Apparently, BMW don't offer an oil service, even tho that is what my car says it wants. Bye bye BMW.......hello Autobhan Halesowen, my local indi.
 
It was for Oil and micro filter. It would be £200 if i went against BMW advice and just changed the oil. I started to argue that the car had an inspection 1 last time and was due an oil service, as per the laid out service plan......but thought what am I doing? Why argue? Phoned the indi who agreed an oil service was due and quoted £200 for oil and filter, still steep, but they have good reviews and are used to working on the S54. Also, I need to get a relationship going with a local indi for future works.
 
AldridgeZ4 said:
I was going to keep my service history full BMW, but at £612 for an oil service at Sytner, I don't think so. Apparently, BMW don't offer an oil service, even tho that is what my car says it wants. Bye bye BMW.......hello Autobhan Halesowen, my local indi.

The operative that you spoke to probably thought you meant Inspection 1 which is about £600 at main dealer.

An oil service at main dealer is £285.

Most indies will do this for you from £130 - £180.
 
In fact I’ve just realised that BMW are even bigger thieves than I initially thought.

An oil service for a Z4M is £200, yet an oil service for an E46 M3 is £285.

Both cars share the same engine and take the same amount and grade of oil (5.5 litres of 10w60) so how on earth did they work that one out. :?

E2D136BA-1A44-4D98-9352-D7449C0915B8.png

0CCC2AFD-2D5D-458C-98D6-24FA40CD312B.png

8A05EB50-EC84-425E-831F-12A6114B6DEE.png

D5F3BCE3-1B5F-4C14-9241-C53B37431CDE.png
 
R60BBA said:
AldridgeZ4 said:
I was going to keep my service history full BMW, but at £612 for an oil service at Sytner, I don't think so. Apparently, BMW don't offer an oil service, even tho that is what my car says it wants. Bye bye BMW.......hello Autobhan Halesowen, my local indi.

The operative that you spoke to probably thought you meant Inspection 1 which is about £600 at main dealer.

An oil service at main dealer is £285.

Most indies will do this for you from £130 - £180.

I'm sure you are correct and I tried to explain a few times, but she wouldn't listen. Never mind, hopefully I can develop a good relationship with my indi. I need a few things doing over the next 12/18 months, so it will be good to make contact and have a look around in a couple of weeks.
 
AldridgeZ4 said:
R60BBA said:
AldridgeZ4 said:
I was going to keep my service history full BMW, but at £612 for an oil service at Sytner, I don't think so. Apparently, BMW don't offer an oil service, even tho that is what my car says it wants. Bye bye BMW.......hello Autobhan Halesowen, my local indi.

The operative that you spoke to probably thought you meant Inspection 1 which is about £600 at main dealer.

An oil service at main dealer is £285.

Most indies will do this for you from £130 - £180.

I'm sure you are correct and I tried to explain a few times, but she wouldn't listen. Never mind, hopefully I can develop a good relationship with my indi. I need a few things doing over the next 12/18 months, so it will be good to make contact and have a look around in a couple of weeks.

It gets worse, check my latest post.

But going forward and with the age of these cars, I wouldn’t trust a main dealer unless I had bought a car from them and it was the same service manager from day one.

It’s good that you’ve found and indie and should no longer have to put up with such farces.
 
BMW have applied the new service regime to older cars where it's not applicable, which is why we are seeing the anomalies.

Oil might be more for the M3, but they are quoting a dam sight less for an inspection 2. Z4M £1224, M3 £926 :? :? :?
 
So a main dealer quotes £612 for just an oil service - that sounds plain crazy.

Cooper Chelmsford quoted me £395 (inc VAT) for an Inspection 2. Initially they quoted £629 over the phone, but then £395 when I got there and spoke to the service guy in person - go figure!
 
Some of those prices make your eyes water! I’ve just booked my E89 3.0i for an oil service at an independent in Bradford for £125 all in including VAT.
 
Tinker15 said:
Some of those prices make your eyes water! I’ve just booked my E89 3.0i for an oil service at an independent in Bradford for £125 all in including VAT.
That sounds a bit on the low side.
 
maxman said:
Tinker15 said:
Some of those prices make your eyes water! I’ve just booked my E89 3.0i for an oil service at an independent in Bradford for £125 all in including VAT.
That sounds a bit on the low side.

On the M4 BMW quote £151 for just an oil service. So that’s probably about right for an Indy on a E89
 

Attachments

  • 649F5D90-1721-47F8-9102-50CA17A0E2FB.png
    649F5D90-1721-47F8-9102-50CA17A0E2FB.png
    128.3 KB · Views: 1,036
Angie4m said:
maxman said:
Tinker15 said:
Some of those prices make your eyes water! I’ve just booked my E89 3.0i for an oil service at an independent in Bradford for £125 all in including VAT.
That sounds a bit on the low side.

On the M4 BMW quote £151 for just an oil service. So that’s probably about right for an Indy on a E89

How much oil does the S55 engine take?
 
I am lucky a very good Indi BMW garage is very close to my home. Guy called "Mark Purcell" . He use to look after my old mans E46 M3 Cab.

When the stupid bracket broke on my exhaust t'other week, dad phoned Mark up last min of the day and he looked at what was causing the issue. He had a quick look over my "M" and told dad it looked a pretty clean example. He was told that we wanted him to look after it, which is why he made some time so we knew what to tell the dealer what needed fixing.
 
Angie4m said:
R60BBA said:
Angie4m said:
On the M4 BMW quote £151 for just an oil service. So that’s probably about right for an Indy on a E89

How much oil does the S55 engine take?

7 litres for an oil service.

That doesn’t make any sense :rofl:

An S55 engine takes an extra 1.5 litres of 10w60 oil than a S54 engine, yet the price of an oil service is £49 cheaper than Z4M and £135 cheaper than E46 M3.
 
Back
Top Bottom