6 year old battery - Jump start or replace?

ranski said:
Looks like a calculated risk, even if you follow the guidelines

http://www.bimmerinfo.com/jump_starting_your_BMW.htm


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Going for a very good price, must be demand for LHD cars.
 
Be interested to see where a warranty claim for 'fried ECU' goes if there was a known instance of 'jump starting' ... also if there was a CAT claim, would a 'bump start' negate the claim? :?
 
srhutch said:
ranski said:
Looks like a calculated risk, even if you follow the guidelines

http://www.bimmerinfo.com/jump_starting_your_BMW.htm


Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

Going for a very good price, must be demand for LHD cars.

this article says that voltages over 15v can cause damage, if your jumping from another car then that will only be 13 or 14V, still i'd now be more cautious
 
The bump starting thing is because of unburnt fuel as mentioned. The fuel will wreck the catalyst - partly why diesels have DPF's that belch black smoke. The ECU thinks it should be fuelling but there's no spark to ignite it.

Regarding the ECU thing - only a guess but:
A lot of alternators these days are controlled by the ECU so that it's managing the output of the alternator and the load on it. Putting a second car on the end of it potentially adds an unknown quantity wanting a big whack of power. Another possibility off the top of my head, is that when there's the initial required power surge down the jump leads to turn the starter, it will lower the voltage on the donor car's ECU - to compensate it then draws more current than it should. (Slightly similar idea - in old houses where the room lights dip if you turn on something needing a lot of power like a hoover). It momentarily takes a hell of a lot more voltage/current to start a motor from stationary then it does to run it at a constant speed.
 
Back
Top Bottom