296 19" wheels

Z4 Beemer

Senior member
 Glasgow
Ok, as some of you will know, I'm currently deciding what to do with my 2 and a half year old sDrive 23i... basically keep it and extend the warranty, or... :?

One thing that has been worrying me is would BMW pay to replace one of the 19" wheels if the car was out of the 3 years warranty, but covered by an extended comprehensive warranty.

I thought I would see what BMW Customer Services had to say on the matter, so I emailed them:

____________________________

...One thing that is concerning me is that several other Z4 owners have had issues with the 296 style 19" wheels cracking, and I believe that they have been replaced under factory warranty with no charge, as long as there are no signs that the wheels have been damaged by a pothole.

My car is fitted with the 296 style 19" wheels, and so far I have had no issues with them. I wonder if you can clarify whether they would be covered under the Comprehensive extended warranty if they were to crack after 3 years of ownership?

I appreciate your response on this, and it will help inform my decision on whether I will keep the car and extend the warranty, which is what I would like to do, or whether it would make sense in the longer term to sell it to avoid possible unexpected future costs.

____________________________

They replied back to me with the following:
____________________________

I can advise that alloy wheels are not covered under warranty, however, as with any damaged component, should the defect be due to a manufacturing issue and not external influences, your local BMW Approved Dealership are able to assess the case for a goodwill contribution. Goodwill is seen as reciprocal and we would expect owners to have shown their goodwill by purchasing and maintaining their vehicles within our dealer network.

The vehicles age, mileage, purchase and service history plus an Insured Warranty cost is all taken into consideration when assessing claims of this nature.

I trust that this information clarifies your enquiry, however, please do not hesitate to contact me, if I can be of further assistance.

Yours sincerely

____________________________

I'm taking the view that if they develop a crack, and the dealer observes that the car has been looked after, not particularly high mileage (only just hit 10K), no signs of pothole damage, under warranty (factory or comprehensive extended) and been serviced by local dealer, then hopefully they would be replaced free of charge.

This has sort of put my mind at rest... but can those of you that have had them replaced actually confirm whether BMW states that they are being replaced due to a "manufacturing issue".
 
Replaced but no liability admitted :roll:
Just got it back after service with new ones after they tried the pothole and sending for testing thing when booking it in, and I told them I wasn't having any of it.
Ps 20 k miles done in just ove 2 years :thumbsup:
 
Knowing how much I fought.. I wouldn't read 'free of charge' I'd read 'if you can prove you didn't do it, we'll go halves'.

I've had replacement 296s for a few months now, just had them checked and they've got flat spots, even if minor. They're just not good wheels. Brace yourself!

Frankly though I wouldn't let crap wheels affect your choices as the cost of trading the car may be worse than paying for a few duff wheels.

Best of luck tho, all us 296 wheel peeps need it!

(they still look fab tho)
 
This
DSC01893.jpg



is better than this though
bf15271c.jpg
 
Shame really because I think of the 296s as the signature wheel of the E89, just as I always loved the ellipsoids on the E85. If they were getting replaced under warranty would they let you choose something else?
 
Chris Z4 said:
I have a pair of genuine rear 296 style wheels for sale on the "for sale section" :thumbsup: Buy them as spares :D

You have my attention.. Can you take pictures of the wheels please, specifically the one you mention may have been refurbed. I may consider these as replacements in case I have other wheel issues or indeed to pop them on now because I'm convinced I have something wrong with one of mine (vibration at low speed). But pictures would be very helpful.
 
Back
Top Bottom