Thinking about a BMW M2….or…?

Franzino

Active member
I test drove a e92 M3 V8 (with DKG) for a week and decided this was not the daily car for my needs…. A lovely car and a great engine but you have to drive it really fast to really enjoy it…the car begs to be driven fast and on public roads that's not possible. I also drove a BMW M4 (with DKG). I really did not like this car; It felt to big, I did not like the noise, the steering feel, the traction and the power delivery.

Now there is the M2…it is about the same size as the e46M3 and for me that is the perfect size of a daily car. I don’t like big cars… I also don’t get it why every generation of 3-series has to be bigger then the last one :o

The M2 (with manual transmission) sounds great on paper and every review is really positive about the car. Most car journalist love it…mmmm that caught me thinking and maybe I will love it to? Who knows! So I have arranged a test drive with a M2...sadly it is one with M-DKG transmission, but most people will order this one. So I can understand that they have this M2 for a test car. I will know in 2 weeks how it drives.

On picture I was not fully convinced about the M2 look (I also don’t like that blue color)…but last week I saw one in real life, in the right color (black)… The front bumper is not so nice (the one on the M3/M4 is way more subtle), but in black it looks rather nice and the overall look is good. The wheels are in 2-color and that is something I also don’t like, but I think a respray in ferric grey can solve this for me and maybe fit different wheels one day (like the ones on the 1M).

But what if I like the BMW M2…what then? Should I buy/order one for 2017 delivery? I already have a BMW-M…do I need a BMW-M as my daily car and what will this do with my feeling about my Z4M?

I’m a little afraid that driving everyday with a BMW-M will make my beloved Z4M feel less special and less intoxicating then now. My daily car is now a 12 year old e46 325i estate with full M-tech + Bilstein suspension and every option (manual transmission). I drive my Z4M on my free days when the weather is good or when I go on a track day… The Z4M does 15.000km a year….my 325i touring (daily) does 18.000km a year..

Also when going to my monthly trackday (Nurburgring) will I be tempted to take the M2 instead of my modified Z4M (Bilstein PSS-10 suspension + AP brakes all round + CSL wheels, etc)…. My Z4M is the one I also intended/bought for the occasional track use.

Other alternative cars on the list of replacing my daily 325i are; a used Alpina B3 Bi-Turbo estate (2014 / non X-drive) / used C63 AMG estate (2012/2013). I'm thinking that maybe the Alpina B3 estate is the best daily choice for me and makes the most sense. It is also more of a different car then my Z4M… A BMW M2 is maybe a little bit more in the same region as my Z4M…..? But it could be that I really love how the M2 drives :oops:
 
+1 for the Alpina - great looking machine and different enough from your zed. Pics when you're sorted please :) :)
 
Ordered a M2 today....and yes the Z4M roadster stays also...
My garage is going to be awesome and I can hardly beleive it :)
New school vs Old school.... Coupe vs Roadster... Turbos vs NA....
Z4M for sun and fun and some track....M2 for daily traffic and some track!

I have till the end of this month to decide between M-DCT or manual on my M2 order... Difficult decision :o
 
GuidoK said:
I expect the manual will hold value better. It's a car that for purists.
True....
Buy I bought the M2 for me and for me to enjoy at this moment! I have zero interest in future value. If that was my concern I would not drive my Z4M on the Nurburgring that much and that hard like I do! That's not good for the future value ;) It's my car, not the next owners car....and I tend to keep my cars for a very long time. The M2 replaces my daily e46 325i that has been my daily car for 11 years....my Z4M is with me for 6 years (and is here to stay). So future value is not my concern....I wil buy M-DCT or a manual only on my own personal preference, but I value views and opinions from other car enthousiasts :)
 
So then its a really easy choice. Buy the one you want... :lol:
Asking that question here makes it highly rethorical.
 
GuidoK said:
So then its a really easy choice. Buy the one you want... :lol:
Asking that question here makes it highly rethorical.
Like I said I done't know what to choose and I value views and opinions from other car enthousiasts :)
In the end I will buy on my own personal preference and not for future value...but it is nice to have opinions from others in helping me make this decission ;)
 
Franzino said:
In the end I will buy on my own personal preference and not for future value...but it is nice to have opinions from others in helping me make this decission ;)

that's an interesting contradiction :wink:

From a purist' pov: buy the manual.
 
For a true daily, you can't beat an automatic, especially for town and cruising. For driving and enjoyment for roads where changing gear is necessary then you can't beat a manual, but for daily driving the convenience of dct can't be ignored, plus you can work on your left foot breaking :)
So depends on what style your daily driving takes, but nice position to be in :thumbsup:
 
Back
Top Bottom