Trackit said:
My initial searches have been for an Auto but a few nice manuals have come up, any problems with manual? It seems that autos are more sought after than manuals, is that the case. Just trying to understand the pro’s and cons and get peoples thoughts.
Hi and welcome to the forum.
My 2p worth:
Personally I would forget the 28i. They are for people who are not 'in the know' and pay a massive premium over an 18i or 20i. An E89 28i is identical to the other two, apart from a different engine map (all for BMW marketing purposes) and the 28i has slightly larger front brakes and IIRC comes with auto dimming mirrors as standard.
An 18i or 20i can be re-mapped by anyone on your drive for £250 ish. The maps are perfectly safe and raise power and torque to just over the standard 28i figures.
The cam chain tensioner seems largely to only be a problem with high miles, as it is a wear issue. There are many E89s out there with very low miles as many are used just as summer toys.
Auto or manual is down to personal choice IMHO. The manual gearboxes are good, and much simpler than an auto so less to go wrong. The autos (ZF presumably) are also good, there are millions of them in many different cars. Personally I think a Z4 should be manual as it is a sort of 'sportscar'. Just my opinion of course.
I have a white 2013 18i m-sport manual (remapped to 260bhp) with 27k miles, full history and a good spec I want to get shot of but the wife won't let me! :?
Good luck with your search. Just watch for cracked and repaired wheels, especially the 19" 326Ms, although none are immune. Also check the roof works easily several times and definitely check under the boot floor around the roof hydraulic pump and battery for water or signs of water staining as they have a habit of leaking from below and above!
They are really good cars, though