My F20 125d review

Mowflow

Senior member
 Glasgow
This is a review that i did for another site so thought I would share it here. At the time of writing I had lived with the car 3 months. Since pics/writing I have put the summer wheels back on (style 386 M shod with PZero run flats).

Anyway, here's the review.

Design
It's but ugly………

In all seriousness, much like the last 1 series (and nearly every new BMW for that matter) the new F20 is a bit of a marmite car or for some a grower. I doubt many people could say they loved it from the first time they set eyes on it and I will happily admit that when the f20 was first released I thought it was horrible. My opinion on it's looks changed somewhat when they brought out the M Sport. As always the additional styling gave the car a more purposeful look with lower suspension, gloss grey rear diffuser, 18" alloys and more aggressive front spoiler as standard.

I've mentioned a few times on here that I'm a designer so i could waffle on for hours with a flowery design rational which i know you would all appreciate but sadly I've just not got the time.

Interior
Having owned a previous 1 series this was perhaps the biggest surprise for me. Both in terms of quality and design. It also feels like quite a step up from the 2006 e90 that i had.

The dash has the classic BMW driver focussed feel to it with the centre console turned slightly towards the driver. The centre console running over the transmission tunnel sits quite high which gives both front occupants a very cosseted feeling more akin to what you get in a coupe. As usual the BMW sport seats are excellent. I suffer from general back issues and often find on long journeys my lower back can get that strange feeling like it's going numb. I suffer none of this in the f20 even on long journeys and at 6'1" with long legs I find no problem in getting a perfect driving position. My car is a manual and unlike many of the other cars i looked at the pedals are not offset to a noticeable degree (why is this so common now?)

Standard equipment is good. The usual lovely chunky M Sport steering wheel and now iDrive is standard. The cruise control has now been added to the steering wheel rather than the stalk. In my opinion the function of this isn't as intuitive as the old stalk. The one criticism from the driving seat would be that the centre/airbag on the wheel is too chunky. It is almost impossible to find a good driving position where you can see the bottom of the dash. this really bothered me at first but it's just the mileage that is obscured so there really isn't much need to see it.

In terms of space it is larger in every way than the previous 1 series. i felt it almost as large as my e90, it certainly seems as wide. Rear leg room is just enough for adult passengers although I would imagine it would be uncomfortable on a long journey. The boot is plenty big enough and I would say they could have sacrificed 1inch of boot space to more rear leg room.

On the road
Despite having sport suspension (non adaptive) and 18" run flats the car is very comfortable. When out on an initial test drive in a 118d i winced when I spotted a pothole too late to avoid. I was amazed at the lack of thud as we hit it. However, when pressing on the car does not wallow or roll in bends, quite the contrary.

In my opinion the chassis is very good. On my initial test drive I found that the 50/50 weight distribution of the car was very noticeable and the rear wheel drive shove very distinct. This was the first time that i had noticed this to such an extent in any BMW.

The car features the drive dynamic thingy that all BMW have now. This gives Eco pro, comfort, sport & sport + modes. Eco pro is akin to swimming in custard, comfort is fine for every day driving, sport and sport + makes the car very responsive in terms of throttle response and also weights up the servotronic steering. Some feel it can be too heavy but i find it is just about right for me and wish it could be set to this with the other modes.

The engine is the N47 lump so sadly it's missing 2 cylinders, the timing chain will probably snap and it's about as refined as a night out with Gaza. Thankfully it does come with 2 borg warner blowers attached so that makes up for it a bit. The engine produces 218bhp and 450Nm of torque. The power is spread very evenly throughout the rev range, you don't get that usual big lump of power then a top end wheeze that is common with 4 pot diesels. Torque maxes out at around 4700 rpm but it still pulls up to the red line.

Quite a few owners have commented that the car doesn't feel quick and i was inclined to agree with them until recently. A drive last Friday on some amazing twisty roads in the sunshine has completely changed my mind. The thing with the car is that it really rewards you when you wind it up and throw it about by the scruff of the neck. On a motorway it will drive along very civilised but hit a back road, wind it up a bit like a NA petrol, keep it in that sweet spot and I defy you not to have fun. I also had a play with an 05 modified WRX the other day (on a private motorway style track of course) and the 125 kept up no bother until triple figures where it actually crept ahead.

Economy
Unlike the 123d which this car replaces this car actually is economical. Around 90% of my driving is my commute which is 60 miles per day 50/50 motorway/town in traffic. Over 4200miles in 3 and a bit months I have averaged 49.5mpg using Fuelly. The computer is showing 51.7mpg so pretty accurate. The worst i have managed was 40mpg driving like an absolute dick and the best has been 62mpg driving like a nun but without using eco pro.

Here are a few dodgy pics. The car is wearing it's plastidipped winter wheels/tyres in these pics (the plastidip keeps them good and means I don't have to clean them so often).







 
:thumbsup:

Personally I like the looks, although I notice you've not included a head-on shot of the front (it's worst aspect IMO). Overall I like it and LOVE the idea of a M135i in a few years, but I'm probably too used to the space inside the e90. Interesting to hear you don't find it too small being a previous e90 owner.

On a side note, do you mind divulging the photoshoot location? I'm looking for a more industrial backdrop compared to my usual choice of scenery (PM if you're willing to share!)
 
In terms of size I find it closer to the e90 than to the previous 1 series which we had 4 years ago. I remember reading that the f20 is actually wider than the e90. I'm not sure that's correct but having done a few family trips in it, it's big enough for all four of us.

The location is in Gourock. Bit of a trek for you. My preferred location is usually the old rope works building on the a9 near Port Glasgow but I couldn't be arsed driving their this time.
 
quite like the MSport versions myself - much nicer than the normal styling.

how about some photo's of the other little french hatchback you mentioned?
 
Just bought an F21 118d SPORT manual for Mrs2Alps new high-miles-requiring job, and have to say, we are both totally smitten. We test drove the Msport kitted version and have to disagree with you on the styling: the Msport is a bit garish in our opinion, but each to their own as ever. It also rode a touch stiffer than the non-Msport setup, but similarly to your report, Sport-spec rides and grips brilliantly. I was very tempted to take their M135i out, but felt it would be lacking a touch of 'go' for my liking :P and I couldn't get on with the interior materials at all.

Now, as regards the lump you have: that was taken from the ALPINA D3Biturbo: the last car I had. It's a brilliant diesel engine and it makes an awful lot of sense for BMW to have taken it to replace the old x25d lumps. A sad loss to ALPINA, though :| Utterly, infatuously brilliant engine, and barely noticeable as a derv when 'beaning' it. Enjoy it: I most certainly did in the much heavier E90 chassis. We had to go for economy over outright performance to make our F21 ownership 'pay' but the 118d is no slouch at all (my B3SBT does a 0-60 in well under 5s, so I know how to hustle on) and that little thing is always on-turbo and willing, plus we're getting between 52 and 57mpg in real world driving! It's easing Mrs2Alps transition from her Roadster S very nicely, indeed, and she's mightily happy with it. A fine steed.

The F20/21 are leagues ahead of the predecessors in every respect, including appearance :!: Interior quality I'd put on a par with my LCI E90, maybe a fraction better in one or two areas, lacking in others.
 
I also had an e90, albeit a pre LCI but I agree that the quality is on a par with that.

I test drove a 118d. The ride and handling was identical to mine and as you say the engine had more than enough go for most people. I test drove offerings from the usual suspects before ordering this car. I wasn't sure if I was going petrol or diesel so the choices were a bit of a mixed bag. They were new A3 1.8tfsi, A250 AMG, Mk6 Golf GTD/GTi (the new golf wasn't out at the time). They were all fine cars but the F20 with any engine just seemed to have a more balanced chassis and rewarding drive compared to any of the others. I don't normally buy into the usual sales crap that the BMW salesmen spiel you about "A BMW being a drivers car" but I really had to agree in this case when compared to the competition. Surprisingly the closest thing to it was the Ford Focus.
 
Great review Mowflow, they should have put that engine in the zed instead of the 18i
 
Mowflow said:
I also had an e90, albeit a pre LCI but I agree that the quality is on a par with that.

I test drove a 118d. The ride and handling was identical to mine and as you say the engine had more than enough go for most people. I test drove offerings from the usual suspects before ordering this car. I wasn't sure if I was going petrol or diesel so the choices were a bit of a mixed bag. They were new A3 1.8tfsi, A250 AMG, Mk6 Golf GTD/GTi (the new golf wasn't out at the time). They were all fine cars but the F20 with any engine just seemed to have a more balanced chassis and rewarding drive compared to any of the others. I don't normally buy into the usual sales crap that the BMW salesmen spiel you about "A BMW being a drivers car" but I really had to agree in this case when compared to the competition. Surprisingly the closest thing to it was the Ford Focus.

erm, this is shocking. We tried he same cars in petrol and derv (but the Golf 7, both engine types) the new SEAT Leon and others. Sadly the Focus we tried was the 1.0T and it was unpleasant. As was the styling and 'quality'. It was the cheapest in DERV form, though, with suitable seats (I have a chronic debilitating back problem, so seats are a source of high scrutiny). The best we drove was the Golf 7 (both engines were fine, but the 1.4TSi 144 is a peach (Father in law has jsut ordered one after we told him how good it was), but it is goddam dull. The wife got a brand new 2.0TDi Golf 7 from Europcar to do a 200mile trip in and came back stating 'I'm so glad we ordered the F21'. BTW, what is it with that stupid electric parking brake on the A-class? Totally counter-intuitive. And inside? WTF :o

The F21 was a bit left-field as living where we are includes a journey through the Welsh hills to get to a straight road, so winter time was a concern on RWD as the hills get snow regularly which we never see at home. BUT a bit of investigating later and I found the winters we have for the Roadster S fit the F21. So we tried it, and bought it, as it was easily the best car we test drove. Wifey doesn't need outright grunt for her mile-eater, and the 118d is more than sufficient and gives us the returns we need to make the purchase and running of it viable. It was also, surprisingly, much cheaper to buy than the competition on like-for-like finance deals.

If she needs a fix of driving far too fast at scenery, she will take a drive in my B3SBT :rofl: Just don't tell her I offered that :lol:
 
I hate electronic parking brakes full stop. The A3 also had a push button one and the thing that struck me about both the A3 and the A class was that it was changed from the norm for no good reason. There was just a kind of useless void where it should have been. The A class was even worse because the one i drove only came in auto and for some reason it doesn't even have an auto controller type stick so the centre console is just like a big useless plastic shelf. i found the new A3 interior was too similar to my old A3 and the A class was trying too hard to look sporty. It was also very cramped in the back with the smallest boot.

Funnily enough i live right on the west coast of Scotland at the very top of some steep hills which lead to moors. I picked up a set of brand new F20 alloys with new continental winter contact 3s on for half the dealer price (£650). We have a 4x4 but I actually found that the f20 on winter tyres drove better and got up the hills no problem at all. I was absolutely amazed at how much of a difference the tyres make.
 
Mowflow said:
I hate electronic parking brakes full stop. The A3 also had a push button one and the thing that struck me about both the A3 and the A class was that it was changed from the norm for no good reason. There was just a kind of useless void where it should have been. The A class was even worse because the one i drove only came in auto and for some reason it doesn't even have an auto controller type stick so the centre console is just like a big useless plastic shelf. i found the new A3 interior was too similar to my old A3 and the A class was trying too hard to look sporty. It was also very cramped in the back with the smallest boot.

Funnily enough i live right on the west coast of Scotland at the very top of some steep hills which lead to moors. I picked up a set of brand new F20 alloys with new continental winter contact 3s on for half the dealer price (£650). We have a 4x4 but I actually found that the f20 on winter tyres drove better and got up the hills no problem at all. I was absolutely amazed at how much of a difference the tyres make.

I fell out with the electric handbrake on one of the Golfs we were loaned....it just would not automatically release. My wife had no such issues! The Merc is odd as it's pull off, push on IIRC (anyway, the reverse of what you'd expect) and it's tucked UNDER to the RHS of the steering column. Which bright designer thought that through :oops:

We live at the bottom of all hills as we're literally West coast and it's all uphill outta here! I'm sure she will cope on winters: thus far we've lived here 8 years and she's coped in all weathers on summer tyres on any car we've owned (inc E46, RS, RX-8) and anything thrown at her by the hire companies, but we have to expect the worst weather just in case and I'd hate her to get stuck on her way home.

BMW leads the way in this segment, still, if you want a fine driving and handling machine with no fripperies.
 
Back
Top Bottom