Fan / water sensor

[Dave 2 dogs]

Hi all , been a while .
Just not been as enthusiastic with the car this year for personal reasons.
I’m after some help please…
The water fan is coming on , and going off, intermittent ,
Even from cold start , which kind of points towards the coolant sensor, I know there are 2 …. One at the top which is the temperature sensor, and then the fan sensor. It’s this I’m struggling with, looked at a couple of videos, and it shows it on the bottom radiator hose in the video. But it’s not there on mine. Anyone know where else this might be please?
It’s a 35.i 2013 e89
Thanks in advance

 

[B21]

Have you read the error codes…this behaviour is sometimes associated with failing water pump..

 

[Dave 2 dogs]

Hi B21
Just borrowed a code reader , I’ll be using it this afternoon, I’ll let you know how it pans out
Thanks for the info and the water pump
Hope it’s all good your end

 

[Dave 2 dogs]

Put the code reader on the car and it came up with these

 

[B21]

Yes it’s a knackered water pump..

 

[Dave 2 dogs]

Thanks B21
Going in for the assessment next Friday, any idea on costs ?
Thanks mate

 

[B21]

Thanks B21
Going in for the assessment next Friday, any idea on costs ?
Thanks mate

Pump is around £320 from Indy sources…need to do thermostat at the same time around £80…probably 4-5 hours labour..

I’d imagine at BMW it’s over a grand..probably closer to £1,500…

 

[Dave 2 dogs]

Thanks mate

 

[Dave 2 dogs]

Just an update
Mainly for B21
Yep , knackered pump
Replaced both pump and thermostat as stated .
Got out for 2 quid short of £1k
Thought I’d let you know .
Thanks mate

 

[B21]

Just an update
Mainly for B21
Yep , knackered pump
Replaced both pump and thermostat as stated .
Got out for 2 quid short of £1k
Thought I’d let you know .
Thanks mate

Thnx for getting back..always good to hear what the close out was..

 

[enuff_zed]

Just an update
Mainly for B21
Yep , knackered pump
Replaced both pump and thermostat as stated .
Got out for 2 quid short of £1k
Thought I’d let you know .
Thanks mate

Jeez! How much of that is labour?

 

[matsmith749]

It's a big job - book says 6 hours for water pump on it's own.

I'm assuming this was an indy, so likely £500 - £600 of that bill was labour.

Always feels like a spanking, but I guess they gotta eat & premises / tools / ramps don't pay for themselves.

 

[The.Analyst]

Mine went at 55k

Mate and I did the job

It’s not easy

We took a weekend working slowly at it

Wish I’d taken it to my Indy

 

[Dave 2 dogs]

Just an update
Mainly for B21
Yep , knackered pump
Replaced both pump and thermostat as stated .
Got out for 2 quid short of £1k
Thought I’d let you know .
Thanks mate

Jeez! How much of that is labour?

My guy did it in 3 hours. The pump was indeed over £500 though

 

[Dave 2 dogs]

It's a big job - book says 6 hours for water pump on it's own.

I'm assuming this was an indy, so likely £500 - £600 of that bill was labour.

Always feels like a spanking, but I guess they gotta eat & premises / tools / ramps don't pay for themselves.

I’m happy with the price , you mentioned the cost of the pump , plus the thermostat, and plus vat . I think it was reasonable to be fair. Like you said. They gotta eat
If I’d booked it with BMW they would have probably said a month or something wait time. Plus much more money. It’s another tick box for things that go wrong on these. Along with the roof fail which I did last year. So less to worry about, and more to enjoy, plus a bit of incentive for the potential buyer when/if I sell