Bottom arm ball joints.

plowy

Active member
If the bottom arm ball joints are shot they will knock over bumps i understand but has anyone experienced the 'knocking' noise it causes because i think mine are gone on the n/s but the noise sounds as if it's comming from within the centre of the dash/bulkhead area, is this how the noise will transmit into the cabin ????
 
Not had a knocking noise, but my Z4 just failed it's MOT for lower arm, ball joint and rear bushes... Not sure I had a knocking though?
 
Check your diagonal strut braces are torqued properly. It's a common problem that they knock/rattle due to insufficient torque setting from the factory. I don't want to scare you but I had a knock from the bulkhead area and it turned out to be a broken weld! If I were you I'd check all the suspension bolts just to make sure nothings come loose.
 
maybe it's the control arm bushings??? i'm taking a wild guess here! i had that same "knock" sound come from the dash area. i had to get the control arm bushings replaced. just a wild guess here*
 
Curtis said:
Check your diagonal strut braces are torqued properly. It's a common problem that they knock/rattle due to insufficient torque setting from the factory. I don't want to scare you but I had a knock from the bulkhead area and it turned out to be a broken weld! If I were you I'd check all the suspension bolts just to make sure nothings come loose.

You might have just nailed it Curtis!!!!!!, i have recently had them off to polish them, anyone know the settings ????
 
HMmmmmm.... :( just checked them though and they are solid ??

Going back to the bottom arm another sign it maybe the n/s one is that today i was over speed bumps and it doesn't knock when the o/s wheel only goes over the bump but the noise sounds to come from the exact place where the diagonal braces bolt to the bulk head, is this a coincidence and it must be the bottom arm ball joints ????
 
mystik said:
maybe it's the control arm bushings??? i'm taking a wild guess here! i had that same "knock" sound come from the dash area. i had to get the control arm bushings replaced. just a wild guess here*

and did this cure the problem ??
 
Why not remove the strut braces completely and go for a test drive. At least you can illiminate them or condemn them that way.
 
plowy said:
mystik said:
maybe it's the control arm bushings??? i'm taking a wild guess here! i had that same "knock" sound come from the dash area. i had to get the control arm bushings replaced. just a wild guess here*

and did this cure the problem ??


yes, it did. no problems since then. it happened in november 2007.
 
Curtis said:
Why not remove the strut braces completely and go for a test drive. At least you can illiminate them or condemn them that way.

Will try this but it might give a false impression, if it is the bottom arm the transmission of the knocking noise is coming through the strut bar and making itself heard at the bulk head.....
 
SORTED....:roundel: ....after much mucking about and riding down the street sat in the engine bay.. :D i located the problem to be at the top of the strut, flipped off the plastic cover housing the nut on top of the shock and it was as loose as a whores nickers..nipped it up and job done... :thumbsup:
 
Back
Top Bottom